Who has the best discography? Miley, Selena, or Demi?

[Zach F]

Who do y'all think has the best one out of the three? 
 

I'm gonna have to go with Demi.

[biczzxangel]

Haven't listened to Miley's discography yet and I've only listened to Demi's album from 2013 to 2017 and Selena's from 2011 to 2020. Cannot say who's better but all i can say is that Revival is Selena's best and Confident or selftitled Demi's.

[descg]

Demi for me.

[ifuseekjoey1]

Demi! Though I love them all

[Fay1981]

Miley.

[Loveprofusion]

Selena/Miley

Demi has “screeching” vocal issues. Tone it down. Seriously bring it down a notch and make a charting pop song sometime this decade 

Edited September 12, 2023 by Loveprofusion

[bitbitboi]

Miley > Selena > Demi

Miley is a star.

Demi has the pipes, but I enjoy Selena's music the most, and she probably has bigger hits (isn't Demi known mostly because of her ballads?)

And where's Hilary and LiLo? To me, they all will always be in the same group/category (except maybe for Miley, who doesn't have a perfect catalogue but it's definitely the biggest musician of them all)

 

Edited September 14, 2023 by bitbitboi

[bitbitboi]

1 minute ago, Loveprofusion said:

Selena/Miley

Demi has “screeching” vocal issues. Tone it down. Seriously bring it down a notch and make a charting pop song sometime this decade 

There's a reason why she dueted with Xtina..... (I loved them together though haha)

[Marlean]

Demi
Miley
Selena

[princessmimi]

It depends:

Are you referring to their music during their Disney era or post Disney?

Because if I had to pick the best discography from their Disney era,

I'd say:

Miley.

 

However as for post Disney,

I'd say: 

Selena.

[cocodeluxe]

Even though I‘m not a big Miley fan, I have to say Miley. She always tried to reinvent herself and has such a diverse music catalogue. She has done dance-pop, hip-hop, country, rock and even an psychedelic experimental album. Demi and Selena have always played it safe with the pop stuff, except for Demi lately, love that she took the risk and made a rock album. I‘m still hoping that Selena will come out with a dark alternative experimental album and surprise us all.

Edited September 12, 2023 by cocodeluxe

[Fab britney]

Miley>Selena>>>>demi

miley just barely edges out Selena cause I think she’s more iconic but Selena’s collabs are top notch and I actually think she’s smart and selective with what she participates in. It ain’t me, calm down, they’re just like major hits 

[Style.]

Miley. Plastic Hearts clears. 
Selena. The Heart Wants What It Wants slay. 
Demi. Cool For The Summer a bop. 

[BUWYGF]

Definitely Miley tbh, she absolutely slayed with her last three albums, constant growth.

Second Selena for me, I love her music but it often lacks depth for me.

Third Demi, some of her songs are fun but I find her music very boring and I fail to connect to it

[Wendy Williams]

I can't choose because idk their albums

[severusvape]

I’d say Miley/Demi. 
 

Demi can get a bit annoying with her vocals though. Miley has the most touching lyrics for me where I can relate to.

Only like 3 or 4 songs from Selena, so can’t really judge on that one.

[jordeezy river red]

Myles.

[MIKE_INT]

For me personally, even Selena is the worst singer (talker) of these three her discography is the most cohesive for me, meaning I can listen almost full album from start to finish without skipping.

Second would be Miley, its always hit or miss with her, 3-4 songs on the album are good and the rest is fluff

Third would be Demi, I literally like just "Cool for the summer" and "Hearattack" from her

[Danielle1987]

I was thinking the answer was obviously Miley 

[i sometimes sing live]

IMO, all of them are mid music-wise. Miley is, by far, the best performer (and a very electric one at that), and at least has some sort of artistic vision. Demi is a great singer, but vocals can't save mediocre music. Personally, I find Selena to be the most palatable, though, because she's very easy to mold into any vibe/subgenre of pop music, and she works with good writers.

Edited September 13, 2023 by i sometimes sing live