Battle of The Pop Stars Round 2: Christina Aguilera vs. Lady Gaga

[Midnight]

6 hours ago, Britney'sBish said:

I'm disappointed that your "Magic Begins At Midnight" tag isn't a link to your OnlyFans...

Why watch me when you can have me 

Spoiler

Spoiler

 

 

 

[Britney'sBish]

On 4/25/2021 at 10:58 AM, Midnight said:

Why watch me when you can have me 

  Hide contents

  Hide contents

 

 

Well now I just creamed my jeans...
 

 

[MyLittlePopstar]

I love both. But for me it’s definitely Gaga. 
 

I can’t at everyone saying Xtina is “the better singer.” Xtina is amazing of course, but as someone who has studied voice I greatly disagree. At least nowadays, her technique has really gone downhill in the past decade. Shouting does not equal singing. I feel like Gaga has better control and tone. For me, the way Xtina sings gets exhausting to listen to, but I could listen to Gaga all the time. Also, I think Gaga had shown more versatility with her voice. She can do big diva ballads, she can do auto tune dance songs, jazz, classical, music theater, etc. I just think she’s smarter with her voice, I think a lot of ppl like music they can sing along to. So she does catchy fun songs you can sing along with, but throws in impressive vocals on ballads too. I feel like Christina, constantly, to this day is still trying to “show off” on every single song. And maybe that’s what her stand like/want but I don’t think it’s great for her career overall. 
 

In terms of discography, I def prefer Gaga. Visuals, Gaga. Tours, Gaga. Performances, Gaga. Personality, Gaga. Lol. 
 

I said this in the Xtina/Beyonce thread, but Xtina used to be my 2nd fave after Britney. But her career choices (and personality) kinda made me lose some interest on her over time. I honestly don’t even listen to Liberation aside from like 3 songs. But I love all of Gaga’s solo albums. And I’ve consistently loved her music and other choices throughout the years. She’s in my top 3. So she definitely gets my vote 

[MyLittlePopstar]

I’m so curious to see where this will go, I feel like you started with some serious powerhouses- Gaga, Xtina, and Beyonce. So is Beyonce out for good now? Like is Demi Lovato gonna come up later and beat Beyonce? Lol 

[thebritmaster]

Christina! Gaga hasn’t had an album yet reach the quality of Stripped and Back to Basics 

[Leolileinstein]

Gaga's Winning YAS! 

[bitbitboi]

On 4/24/2021 at 10:08 PM, Dreams said:

Gaga is very gifted in the visual and fashion department (even tho she didn't invent anything but she's a good mimic)

Gaga is great at making people believe that her basic ordinary generic pop music is something "deeper" with the help of aesthetics , false deep concepts and visuals, she knows how to compensate the lack of flavor/substance with mental gymnastics and fake try hard edgy concepts to embellish her very basic music , like for example : ARTPOP and Chromatica sound very generic and boring if you remove the concept. It always feels her music isn't really reflective of how weird she thinks she is.

Christina on the other end, has better albums (at least in the early 00s). Her pop persona feels a bit less cookie-cutter and manufactured to me. And she has a more unique voice tone. Stripped and B2B are better than any Gaga album.

 

I'm gagged..... The way you spilled, b/tch!

Now give the children some time to process, please.

 

Spoiler

Everything you said is true, but I looooove Gaga's music though... And "Chromatica" is CUTE!

 

[Dussiniers]

I thought it was the same person you know... oreos and stuff 

[Midnight]

1 hour ago, MyLittlePopstar said:

I’m so curious to see where this will go, I feel like you started with some serious powerhouses- Gaga, Xtina, and Beyonce. So is Beyonce out for good now? Like is Demi Lovato gonna come up later and beat Beyonce? Lol 

Yes Beyonce is out  

Knowing exhales taste I bet Demi would beat Beyonce for sure 

[severusvape]

Christina.

I never really paid attention to gaga cause her music just doesn’t speak to me. I like maybe one or two songs but that’s it. To each their own.