Lady Gaga 'Chromatica' stream + comment party

[rockztar23]

Pros: Cohesive, short tracks, no ballads, production.

Cons: weak lyrics, not so many singles material, too much effect on her voice.

B+

[MonAmour]

Love Replay and Babylon! This Album is fun and nostalgic, nothing innovative, but signature Gaga sound. Now everyone stfu and be thankful.

[rockztar23]

1 hour ago, SlayOut said:

911 is a bop, written in part by Justin Tranter! Imagine this was the direction for B10! 

Alice, Plastic Doll and Sour Candy are cute songs, I had fun listening to them.  Surprised that I’m actually digging Sine from Above (except the last 20 seconds) 

That was my favorite part actually

[MonAmour]

8 hours ago, wehoyon771 said:

This album is really poor and outdated. There is no one good song. Literally. 

What do you like then?

[MonAmour]

Least favourite: Blackpink song. Seemed desperate.

[monalisaney81]

Britney would have been perfect in Sour Candy tbh

[monalisaney81]

11 minutes ago, rockztar23 said:

Pros: Cohesive, short tracks, no ballads, production.

Cons: weak lyrics, not so many singles material, too much effect on her voice.

B+

The lyrics are not weak. Even a “generic” song like Rain On Me has a deep meaning. If you can’t interpret them then thats something diff but I wouldn’t say the lyrics are weak.

[Body ache]

Just finished listening to this with headphones

Alice 9/10 - Need more plays to give a definite review

Free Woman 9.5/10 - melody is nice, cohesive, solid song

Fun Tonight 5/10 - I feel like she thought she was doing something here by having it in the first half of the album. It's catchy but I wouldn't give this another listen.

911 10/10 - this slaps. It's like artpop (song) but on acid

Plastic Doll 7/10 - sounds like it could fit on Born This Way. A little too noisy for me. I feel like I'm expecting charli xcx to show up any minute in it.

Sour Candy 7.5/10 - the chorus is everything. Need more plays to judge

Enigma 6/10 - Elton should have been on this then maybe it would be an actual song and not a show opener.

Replay 9/10 - that drop is epic. Single worthy.

Sine From Above 8/10 with Elton, 11/10 w/o Elton - I kept wanting his parts to end other than that it's pretty perfect.

1000 Doves 4/10 - I feel like this song wants so bad to happen but it just misses it's mark.

Black Jesus.. I mean Babylon 7/10 - I'm indifferent towards Black Jesus and I feel the same regarding this song but Babylon is better.

 

Top tier

Alice, FW, 911, SFA

Second tier

PD, Replay

 

I think Bloodpop was only necessary for the top tier songs, Gaga should have expanded her sound better and tried something new like she did with 911. Although, she did bring out FameGa for this record which I really missed. It could surpass Artpop and get in her top 3

[palmtrees]

1 hour ago, MANDIXMX said:

Britney would have been perfect in Sour Candy tbh

I wanna hear Britney in this song I feel both voices would blend nicely on this track 

[ExXL]

Best songs on the album are Babylon , replay and 1000 doves , the rest really sounded pretty trash to me , I'll just say 'mood ring' is better than that whole album 

[SouthernOreo]

CHROMATICA IS HER BEST ALBUM SINCE THE FAME MONSTER (and actually Born This Way) AND I SAID WTF I SAID!!

THE WHOOOOOOOLE ALBUM IS LITERALLY A LOVECHILD BETWEEN BORN THIS WAY & ARTPOP

THIS **** SLAPS. UPPERCUTS. PUNCHES. AND SNATCHES!!!!

 

THIS ALBUM...IS A POP ALBUM....AND ITS WHAT WE’VE BEEN MISSING & NEEDING!!!

[Kiey]

Sine From Above would be epic without Elton John

She should have included him in another song and release this as a single solo

 

[Kiey]

And I have a nagging suspicion that Gaga loves FF7 Remake

Her aesthetic for Rain On Me literally felt like it was in that world

even that Jenova in the chamber look

 

[Matiz]

This album is her worst. Even Joanne had great songs. Chromatica is an ok album but nothing stands out. And Plastic Doll is the worst song in her career

[redacted statement]

Glad people are liking it as much as they are because most people didn't seem too hopeful after the singles.  I need to give it another listen. For now, it's a 7/10, and all her other albums (except "Joanne") outsold.  Gaga doesn't have any bad albums, though. I love "Joanne" as well, so this is another good addition to her discography. 

[IamArmin]

I get why people have mixed feelings about this album, but it’s definately a grower. I mean, I love this album but it’s not a 10/10; very European pop infused with 90s house/dance music. I can see this album doing better in Europe to be honest, but we’ll see. I am excited! The album will still do very well. Oh and... THE TRANSITION FROM “Chromatica ll” to “911” IS EVERYTHING!

Faves: Chromatica ll + 911, Sine From Above, 1000 Doves and Babylon. 

GO GAGA!

I’m new here, but so far in love with everybody’s comments! 

[ExXL]

1 hour ago, SouthernOreo said:

CHROMATICA IS HER BEST ALBUM SINCE THE FAME MONSTER AND I SAID WTF I SAID!!

 

THIS **** SLAPS. UPPERCUTS. PUNCHES. AND SNATCHES!!!!

 

THIS ALBUM...IS A POP ALBUM....AND ITS WHAT WE’VE BEEN MISSING & NEEDING!!!

Have you ever heard born this way - hair, edge of glory, Judas*, born this way, bloody Mary, Mary the night , heavy Metal lover etc , the whole album is eating chromatica , both Lyrically and sonically ..... 

[senammoises]

Great album

Way better than her past two albums 

[Jedro]

10 hours ago, bog.bhs said:

I thought Stupid love was bad, but... Most of the album is even worse.

The only tracks worth replaying are Alice, Rain on me and Sour candy. The rest sounds like an outdated Eurovision compilation.

MTE 

[SouthernOreo]

46 minutes ago, ExXL said:

Have you ever heard born this way - hair, edge of glory, Judas*, born this way, bloody Mary, Mary the night , heavy Metal lover etc , the whole album is eating chromatica , both Lyrically and sonically ..... 

Did you miss where I stated “I said what I said”? Yes, I’ve heard all of her albums — I have them. I love Born This Way. Chromatica is damn lovechild between Born This Way & ArtPop. 
 

wait, let me go mention that.