Who's Music is Better: Lindsay Lohan or Hilary Duff?

[2K16NEY]

Hilary Duff all the way. 

Her album Dignity is a pop masterpiece and is better than anything Lindsay has ever put out. 

Breathe In, Breathe Out proves that she still has it in her and I'm sure she can release another great pop album in the near future. 

My favorite Hilary songs:

Stranger

Danger

Gypsy Woman

Metamorphis

Anywhere But Here

Come Clean

My Kind

and the list goes on...

My favorite Lindsay songs:

Rumors

Over

and I believe that's it... although she's got a few cute other songs hehe

[JayTawndre]

On 10/17/2022 at 9:12 AM, 2K16NEY said:

Hilary Duff all the way. 

Her album Dignity is a pop masterpiece and is better than anything Lindsay has ever put out. 

Breathe In, Breathe Out proves that she still has it in her and I'm sure she can release another great pop album in the near future. 

My favorite Hilary songs:

Stranger

Danger

Gypsy Woman

Metamorphis

Anywhere But Here

Come Clean

My Kind

and the list goes on...

My favorite Lindsay songs:

Rumors

Over

and I believe that's it... although she's got a few cute other songs hehe

Ooh you spilled the tea!!! Agreed ❤️

[Marlean]

Lindsay, never cared for Duff. 

[britneyluv]

On 10/17/2022 at 12:12 PM, 2K16NEY said:

Hilary Duff all the way. 

Her album Dignity is a pop masterpiece and is better than anything Lindsay has ever put out. 

Breathe In, Breathe Out proves that she still has it in her and I'm sure she can release another great pop album in the near future. 

My favorite Hilary songs:

Stranger

Danger

Gypsy Woman

Metamorphis

Anywhere But Here

Come Clean

My Kind

and the list goes on...

My favorite Lindsay songs:

Rumors

Over

and I believe that's it... although she's got a few cute other songs hehe

Although Bossy was a bop

[JayTawndre]

13 hours ago, Marlean said:

Lindsay, never cared for Duff. 

Lindsay's music is VERY underrated. I love her recent stuff too that leaked. 🤍

[Viking84]

Lindsay's albums are actually really good. I can't say the same for what I have heard of Hilary's music. Lindsay also has a more pleasant voice even though neither of them can sing live.

[sparrowhawk]

Queen Lindsay, period.

[BeyonceIsQueen]

It’s a tie;  they both lose

[VCTR]

I feel very passionate that anyone who says Lindsay is delusional. That being said, I liked her second album.
 

Hilary just served it every time. Her teen pop was top tier teen pop. Her dance was too tied dance. Her angst was top tier angst. Her Depeche Mode sampling was top tier Depeche Mode sampling (but I still prefer the remix).

[that's hot y'all]

my jam !

 

[IsraeliMatt]

Hilary easily. Both are good...nothing shocking or ground-breaking, but good. I think Hilary's body of work is generally better and she had more time to show off her songwriting skills. However, Lindsay gets points for Confessions of a Broken Heart, which was a beautiful and surprisingly vulnerable ballad, with an impressive video. 

[stanLOONA]

Lindsay with Disney: Ultimate is my bop  and her songs with the Teenage Drama Queen movie

Hilary after Disney: Dignity's singles are hot  and yes, I like Reach Out from her Best Of 

[descg]

Lindsay: Rumours, To Know Your Name, Confessions Of A Broken Heart, Bossy

Hilary: Come Clean, Fly, Stranger, Reach Out

.... Difficult, Hilary have more tracks but Lindsay some a little better.

[kevin.]

i liked both but Hilary Duff has a perfect pop album, Dignity.

 

[crazyasamuthafukka]

Lindsay Lohan! Her vocals is deeper and more nuanced. She is a more natural dancer, and her catalog is flawless. She may have less music, but I think her albums are stronger than Hilary’s. Don’t get me wrong I’m also a Hilary Duff fan, but Lindsay Lohan is one of my favorites.

[DenisMarquina80]

I can't deny Hilary Duff's music career was more successful and I do love her songs but I think Lindsay was way more talented (as a singer and actress).

Lindsay's two albums are amazing, with no skips. 

And talking about cultural impact I think Lindsay Lohan was more iconic too. Her movies  and personal life made her a truly beacon in the landscape of pop culture.

 

[vzlafan]

Hilary duff, stage presence, she was huge and her albums amazing.

[that's hot y'all]

@The JayTawndre Show SIS !!!

our jam ! our anthem !

I'm tired of rumors starting
I'm sick of being followed
I'm tired of people lying
Sayin' what they want about me
Why can't they back up off me
Why can't they let me live
I'm gonna do it my way
Take this for just what it is

I just need to free my mind (my mind)
Just wanna dance and have a good time (good time)

I'm tired of rumors (rumors)
Followed (followed, followed, followed, followed, followed)

What they (follow) me
Why can't they (they they they-they-they) let me live

Take this for just what it is

[that's hot y'all]

My tears are turning into time I've wasted trying to find a reason for goodbye I can't live without you Can't breathe without you I'm dreamin' 'bout you honestly Tell me that its over 'Cause if the world is spinning and I'm still living It won't be right if we're not in it together Tell me that it's over And I'll be the first to go Don't want to be the last to know I won't be the one to chase you

[that's hot y'all]