Who's Music is Better: Lindsay Lohan or Hilary Duff?

[JayTawndre]

Hilary Duff 

or

Lindsay Lohan?

I think they both had really great music. Who would I rather have a new album from.... I would say Hilary Duff honestly. I love Lindsay Lohan's movie comeback era tbh. That's my opinion! 

Discuss... 

[GlitterRain]

Hilary, duh! Lindsay had a few good moments in music but Hilary’s music career wins 

[JayTawndre]

7 minutes ago, GlitterRain said:

Hilary, duh! Lindsay had a few good moments in music but Hilary’s music career wins 

Lindsay secretly reading this like... 

[Adriannn]

Hilary! She had more musical inclination than Lindsay.

However...

 

[JayTawndre]

3 minutes ago, Adriannn said:

Hilary! She had more musical inclination than Lindsay.

However...

 

Underrated banger! 

[IsLindsayLohanLikeOk]

LINDSAY 100%

When I was younger I stanned Hilary Duff but as I grew up and checked out Lindsay's music I realized hers was actually A LOT better. I don't think Hilary's albums lasted the test of time like Lindsay's has  Metamorphosis was ok, some songs really good some absolutely terrible, self titled was cool too but aged like milk I fear, Dignity was half good, breathe in breathe out was terrible (not sorry it sucked)

As for Lindsay I don't think she has any skips in her entire discography except 'I Want You To Want Me' but even then that song washes some of Hilary's bad songs like 'Love Just It', 'I Am', and 'I W*sh' ...

When it comes to unreleased songs Lindsay also absolutely washes Hilary, Lindsay's whole scrapped album is AMAZING, literally a more dance oriented Blackout. I'm not dissing early Hilary music tho, 'Come Clean' was a timeless classic, but you just cant say that for most of her music unlike Lindsay who also created the best song of all time known as 'Over' 

I feel like if you say Hilary had better music you haven't heard any Lindsay song except 'Rumors' so... come on mama let's research.

Some of her best songs in my opinion (which Hilary could not do even if she tried):

Spoiler

 

#Relea***anax 

[Isla]

They’re both equal

[rik]

Hilary has the more iconic music career, as Lindsay’s acting presence was taken way too seriously while Hilary was more of a brand. Lindsay however, had the better voice for live singing (not that she did much of that).

[nwonder]

Tbh imo I think they’re both equally average artists who have gotten lucky with some decent songs here and there I.e rumours, with love, bossy, coming clean 

but if I had to choose I’d probably go with Lindsay 

 

[JayTawndre]

41 minutes ago, IsLindsayLohanLikeOk said:

LINDSAY 100%

When I was younger I stanned Hilary Duff but as I grew up and checked out Lindsay's music I realized hers was actually A LOT better. I don't think Hilary's albums lasted the test of time like Lindsay's has  Metamorphosis was ok, some songs really good some absolutely terrible, self titled was cool too but aged like milk I fear, Dignity was half good, breathe in breathe out was terrible (not sorry it sucked)

As for Lindsay I don't think she has any skips in her entire discography except 'I Want You To Want Me' but even then that song washes some of Hilary's bad songs like 'Love Just It', 'I Am', and 'I W*sh' ...

When it comes to unreleased songs Lindsay also absolutely washes Hilary, Lindsay's whole scrapped album is AMAZING, literally a more dance oriented Blackout. I'm not dissing early Hilary music tho, 'Come Clean' was a timeless classic, but you just cant say that for most of her music unlike Lindsay who also created the best song of all time known as 'Over' 

I feel like if you say Hilary had better music you haven't heard any Lindsay song except 'Rumors' so... come on mama let's research.

Some of her best songs in my opinion (which Hilary could not do even if she tried):

  Hide contents

 

#Relea***anax 

I love all those songs!!!! I love Hilary and Lindsay equally the same 🤍

[ExhaleSpamBot]

[JayTawndre]

23 minutes ago, britney fkn spears said:

Hilary has the more iconic music career, as Lindsay’s acting presence was taken way too seriously while Hilary was more of a brand. Lindsay however, had the better voice for live singing (not that she did much of that).

Hilary does have an iconic music career. Agreed 

[rik]

45 minutes ago, IsLindsayLohanLikeOk said:

LINDSAY 100%

When I was younger I stanned Hilary Duff but as I grew up and checked out Lindsay's music I realized hers was actually A LOT better. I don't think Hilary's albums lasted the test of time like Lindsay's has  Metamorphosis was ok, some songs really good some absolutely terrible, self titled was cool too but aged like milk I fear, Dignity was half good, breathe in breathe out was terrible (not sorry it sucked)

As for Lindsay I don't think she has any skips in her entire discography except 'I Want You To Want Me' but even then that song washes some of Hilary's bad songs like 'Love Just It', 'I Am', and 'I W*sh' ...

When it comes to unreleased songs Lindsay also absolutely washes Hilary, Lindsay's whole scrapped album is AMAZING, literally a more dance oriented Blackout. I'm not dissing early Hilary music tho, 'Come Clean' was a timeless classic, but you just cant say that for most of her music unlike Lindsay who also created the best song of all time known as 'Over' 

I feel like if you say Hilary had better music you haven't heard any Lindsay song except 'Rumors' so... come on mama let's research.

Some of her best songs in my opinion (which Hilary could not do even if she tried):

  Reveal hidden contents

 

#Relea***anax 

Baby don’t be rude, Dignity holds up till this day omg

[lunario]

This >>> the entire career of Hilary

 

[princessmimi]

Whoa does this take me back!

I remember being 10-11 yrs old and loving both of them so much!

But if I honestly had to pick who had better music,

i'd say:

Hilary Duff!

Her early albums are pop PERFECTION especially Metamorphosis and Dignity.

 

Lindsay did have some bops but not as much as Hilary.

I will say though that Lindsay had a stronger singing voice

but she just didnt have the right material to have a long lasting music career.

[Midnight]

Lindsay

[fays1]

Hilary has alot of songs and albums that are decently good, but Lindsay has 2 songs (Over & Rumors) that are better than Hilary's entire career.

[BUWYGF]

Although Lindsay had seriously good bops, I think Hilary is more musically talented and has better music. Not to mention she released more albums that did sell better than Lindsay's

Dignity was literal pop perfection by Hilary, reminds of Blackout so much. And BIBO is such an insanely good album too we should have supported it so much more honestly. 

[jordeezy river red]

Lindsay had a better voice in the beginning but Hilary def sounds good with the technology behind her lol Breathe In Breathe Out was great tho...def could have transformed Hilary into a more authentic pop star if she had stuck with it. 

[Brat]

They have two different musical styles