Selena Gomez x "A Year Without Rain" and "Good For You" appreciation thread

[VCTR]

34 minutes ago, Midnight said:

Let's go back to Hilary and leave it at that 

I'm hijacking this thread to make it a Hilary appreciation thread.

Hey, boo:

 

[Illegally EATEN]

3 minutes ago, VCTR said:

I'm hijacking this thread to make it a Hilary appreciation thread.

Hey, boo:

 

No way hozey  make your own thread !!!!! 

[VCTR]

But I do stan the songs "Tell Me Something I Don't Know", "Undercover", "Good For You", "Hands To Myself", "Kill Them With Kindness", "Bad Liar", "It Ain't Me", and "Rare".

[Illegally EATEN]

Just now, VCTR said:

But I do stan the songs "Tell Me Something I Don't Know", "Undercover", "Good For You", "Hands To Myself", "Kill Them With Kindness", "Bad Liar", "It Ain't Me", and "Rare".

I stan none of those except Good For You nnnn  

[VCTR]

Just now, DonoDotto said:

I stan none of those except Good For You nnnn  

We're both flop Selena fans, but have you ever heard of this Hilary chick? She's sorta underground.

[Illegally EATEN]

9 minutes ago, VCTR said:

We're both flop Selena fans, but have you ever heard of this Hilary chick? She's sorta underground.

Im not a Selena fan 

Hilary's thread has already been made, its titled "Disney Channel songs"  she rocks

[princessmimi]

I love Selena's music especially her Revival album.

She kinda reminds me of Britney cause of how small her vocal range is yet is charming at the same time.

 

[Illegally EATEN]

10 hours ago, princessmimi said:

I love Selena's music especially her Revival album.

She kinda reminds me of Britney cause of how small her vocal range is yet is charming at the same time.

 

I dont think thats a fair comparison 

Britney has a wide vocal range 

Selena does not and requires computers to widen her range 

[Invitation]

I love "A Year Without Rain" & "Round and Round".

"Bad Liar" is one of the best pop songs Selena has done.

[Jordan Miller]

Pop gems

[BritneyWithGlasses]

I remember Alex Russo's and Mason's dance to this... 

 

[Otaner]

19 hours ago, DonoDotto said:

Selena Gomez. I have very strong and founded doubts regarding her singing abilities, but a studio and a computer can work wonders for a persons voice 

"A Year Without Rain" and "Good For You" are undeniably GEMS that deserve appreciation. I LOVE the dream-pop vibe. A Year Without Rain was very out of place in a Disney Channel era album, but its so deep and beautiful. Good For You sounds like Im listening to a song while in a dream. Its so atmospheric! They both are! 

Does anyone else love these songs?

*Bonus question- does anyone else love these songs while thinking Selena Gomez is not a good singer? 
 

I love love love A Year Without Rain... it’s a pop masterpiece. Selena can sing, she has a rare singing voice that not everyone can have to their credit dahhhling... I can hada down say that A Year Without Rain is one of the best pop songs to come out of Disney. It’s a timeless classic and Selena came to deliver !! 

[Illegally EATEN]

48 minutes ago, Otaner said:

I love love love A Year Without Rain... it’s a pop masterpiece. Selena can sing, she has a rare singing voice that not everyone can have to their credit dahhhling... I can hada down say that A Year Without Rain is one of the best pop songs to come out of Disney. It’s a timeless classic and Selena came to deliver !! 

Check out some of the live performances... she couldnt pull it off  they were really really bad and proved her vocals were very manipulated in the studio recording in order to exhibit the range that the song requires. 

[Iconic 4 U]

1 hour ago, Invitation said:

I love "A Year Without Rain" & "Round and Round".

"Bad Liar" is one of the best pop songs Selena has done.

Round & Round is everythingg

[cocodeluxe]

2 hours ago, DonoDotto said:

Check out some of the live performances... she couldnt pull it off  they were really really bad and proved her vocals were very manipulated in the studio recording in order to exhibit the range that the song requires. 

Although Im a big selena fan, you are right. If you listen to the demo you can hear how they obviously layered the vocals in the chorus

 

[princessmimi]

11 hours ago, DonoDotto said:

I dont think thats a fair comparison 

Britney has a wide vocal range 

Selena does not and requires computers to widen her range 

Maybe so but Britney never uses it.

I meant that they both dont sing with high notes

[jcf523]

I used to stan her sooo much, and I still really love her, I’ve seen her live twice. but I find myself not quite as obsessed with her as I used to be. 

[Alex_1991]

She just can't sing. Like, she's literally not a singer. J Lo and Britney, which are considered weak singers, can sing miles over her. She basically doesn't have a singing voice. She has zero range, technique and can't literally hit even the simplest notes. It's inexplicable to me why she's started a singing career in the first place. Jlo can sing decently and Britney can definitely sing. She just can't, it's something she can't do. 

[Isla]

31 minutes ago, Alex_1991 said:

She just can't sing. Like, she's literally not a singer. J Lo and Britney, which are considered weak singers, can sing miles over her. She basically doesn't have a singing voice. She has zero range, technique and can't literally hit even the simplest notes. It's inexplicable to me why she's started a singing career in the first place. Jlo can sing decently and Britney can definitely sing. She just can't, it's something she can't do. 

Ddd are you really bumping an appreciation thread just to say this?