Would you have liked Liar instead of PG?

[IonutM]

We all know that Liar was recorded in 2015. I think it would have been a great ideea to release Liar instead of PG. Also, if Britney really would have wanted a feature on the track she could have chose Lady Gaga(telephone 2.0). Idk why but I see them doing a kickass video for Liar. I dont know about you but Liar is such a BOP, meaningful song and it is in my top 5 songs from Glory. I imagine the video being country like, cowboy oriented about a adventure in the western( you can hear the western influences in last 5-10 sec of the song). This paired with bbma 2015 performance it would have become a hit 

what do you think?

[gonegirl]

i'm down! liar is one of her best glory tracks and it deserved to smash

[Spearsfan]

Liar is the superior song but vocally I think PG is a bit better. The vocals sound like BJ vocals (little we actually got) 

I love Liar and like Clumsy but I can deff tell they were recorded way before the rest of Glory. I wish she would have re recorded them with new vocals in 2016.

They almost sound demoish imo  

[BoyToySoldier]

Do we really know Liar was recorded in 2015? I don't remember any receipts.

[Spearsfan]

1 minute ago, BoyToySoldier said:

Do we really know Liar was recorded in 2015? I don't remember any receipts.

You can tell it's old by the sound. 

I think they were registered then? 

I don't remember but ppl did have receipts

 

[IonutM]

Just now, The Holy Spearit said:

Liar > Explosive diarrhea > Pretty Girls

 straight to the point

[Curiousexhaler86]

Liar has grown on me but I still don't love it. It's noisy in a bad way, and is it just me or does it sound dated af? I do like Britney's attitude tho, you can hear her anger. Still, too noisy of a song for me, don't think it would've done good on the radio.

[Michaelgiftos]

I love that idea with the lady Gaga feature, and video and I think it definitely could've been a hit if that happened. It also could've had a miley Cyrus feature it kinda sounds like her new vibe a little bit.

[DoSomething954]

I love Liar. It sounds like 00s pop song but that's what I love. Britney is amazing when she does those types of pop songs and especially had they released it around the time Meaghan Trainer was bringing that type of pop sound back (lips are moving, all about that bass, etc.), it would have been huge. 

[BoyToySoldier]

10 minutes ago, Spearsfan said:

You can tell it's old by the sound. 

I think they were registered then? 

I don't remember but ppl did have receipts

 

Almost all of Glory sounds like it's from 2015 though. Lol it sounds like Revival / Purpose. And no, it was registered in 2016 along with Man On the Moon a month or two before the album.

[Amanda1822]

Liar is one of my favorites so yes 

[IonutM]

16 minutes ago, Michaelgiftos said:

I love that idea with the lady Gaga feature, and video and I think it definitely could've been a hit if that happened. It also could've had a miley Cyrus feature it kinda sounds like her new vibe a little bit.

yeah, also very nice idea with Miley

[Anti-Hero]

Liar sounds like it’s stuck in the 00s 

[RussianFan]

No way, of course! PG was actually trendy at that point. Liar is so 2001-02 Britney, I mean dated! 

[Spearsfan]

33 minutes ago, BoyToySoldier said:

Almost all of Glory sounds like it's from 2015 though. Lol it sounds like Revival / Purpose. And no, it was registered in 2016 along with Man On the Moon a month or two before the album.

It's not the sound of the song it's thd vocals I'm talking about. They sound off compared to the rest of the album. 

If you can find the original Glory thread I'm pretty sure the discussion of when it was recorded is in there 

[Iexpectyouto]

Part of me says yes cause i love liar and i wish it would've had a release, but I think pg did better success wise than liar would have 

[OutrageousSin]

Hell yeah!! Since the release it quickly became top 3 for me! 

[---]

pg is a **** stain

[Urbanney]

They both suck

[b42ad]

Yes, Liar is an anthem