,,Baby One More Time" vs. ,,Christina Aguilera"? Who had the better debut album?

[BadBunny]

Both released in 1999 by the two premiere pop princesses. 

1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle
2. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. What A Girl Wants
3. Sometimes vs. I Turn To You
4. Soda Pop vs. So Emotional 
5. Born To Make You Happy vs. Come On Over (All I Want Is You)
6. From The Bottom Of My Broken Heart vs. Reflection 
7. I Will Be There vs. Love For All Seasons
8. I Will Still Love You vs. Somebody's Somebody
9. Deep In My Heart vs. When You Put Your Hands On Me
10. Thinkin' About You vs. Blessed 
11. E-Mail My Heart vs. Love Will Find A Way
12. The Beat Goes On vs. Obvious

Who had the better debut album?

 

 

[BadBunny]

1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle
2. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. What A Girl Wants
3. Sometimes vs. I Turn To You
4. Soda Pop vs. So Emotional 
5. Born To Make You Happy vs. Come On Over (All I Want Is You)
6. From The Bottom Of My Broken Heart vs. Reflection 
7. I Will Be There vs. Love For All Seasons
8. I Will Still Love You vs. Somebody's Somebody
9. Deep In My Heart vs. When You Put Your Hands On Me
10. Thinkin' About You vs. Blessed 
11. E-Mail My Heart vs. Love Will Find A Way
12. The Beat Goes On vs. Obvious

BOMT: 4
CA: 8

Christina wins this one in my book!

[darlingbud]

Aren't we all getting a little old for this?

[RadicalOptimism]

Successica why do you always make the same threads girl

[Arabian-boy]

[princessmimi]

3 hours ago, BadBunny said:

Both released in 1999 by the two premiere pop princesses. 

1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle
2. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. What A Girl Wants
3. Sometimes vs. I Turn To You
4. Soda Pop vs. So Emotional 
5. Born To Make You Happy vs. Come On Over (All I Want Is You)
6. From The Bottom Of My Broken Heart vs. Reflection 
7. I Will Be There vs. Love For All Seasons
8. I Will Still Love You vs. Somebody's Somebody
9. Deep In My Heart vs. When You Put Your Hands On Me
10. Thinkin' About You vs. Blessed 
11. E-Mail My Heart vs. Love Will Find A Way
12. The Beat Goes On vs. Obvious

Who had the better debut album?

 

 

It depends because if you are wanting to listen to pure bubblegum pop perfection,

then BOMT is better but if you want soulful r&b style ballads, then Christina's is.

 

I like both albums for those reasons however I obviously favor BOMT.

[JeniLeeSK8]

1. ...Baby One More Time

2. (You Drive Me) Crazy

3. Sometimes

4. Soda Pop

5. Born To Make You Happy

6. Reflection 

7. I Will Be There

8. Somebody's Somebody

9. Deep In My Heart 

10. Thinkin' About You 

11. Love Will Find A Way

12.  Obvious

 

Both albums are fantastic. Britney has more winners track by track for me, however Christina's is more consistently enjoyable for me. No skips

[Almost Mystical]

BOMT is still iconic and talked about 25 years later tho. The same can’t be said to Xtuna’s album. 

[Fall2Pieces]

Call it a personality flaw but i've always liked Christinas debut a lot more 😬

[BadBunny]

7 minutes ago, Fall2Pieces said:

Call it a personality flaw but i've always liked Christinas debut a lot more 😬

It’s obviously a more solid and polished body of work so I don’t blame you. Now when it comes to their albums released in 2002-03, I think ITZ blows Stripped out the water.

[MoodRing3]

[MyLittlePopstar]

1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle
2. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. What A Girl Wants
3. Sometimes vs. I Turn To You
4. Soda Pop vs. So Emotional 
5. Born To Make You Happy vs. Come On Over (All I Want Is You)
6. From The Bottom Of My Broken Heart vs. Reflection 
7. I Will Be There vs. Love For All Seasons
8. I Will Still Love You vs. Somebody's Somebody
9. Deep In My Heart vs. When You Put Your Hands On Me
10. Thinkin' About You vs. Blessed 
11. E-Mail My Heart vs. Love Will Find A Way
12. The Beat Goes On vs. Obvious

 

BOMT: 10 CA: 2

I never listened to Christina’s debut past reflection, I thought all the songs after it were boring 

[The Femme Fatale]

Can we stop trying to stir up Xtuna and Britney drama? Like cmon..

[Jaime Munoz]

Baby one more time of course  it change pop for ever 

the singles  baby one more time, crazy and sometimes are pop history gems 

[rik]

Sweet Kisses  by Jessica Simpson 

[Wendy Williams]

20 hours ago, BadBunny said:

Both released in 1999 by the two premiere pop princesses. 

1. ...Baby One More Time vs. Genie In A Bottle
2. (You Drive Me) Crazy vs. What A Girl Wants
3. Sometimes vs. I Turn To You
4. Soda Pop vs. So Emotional 
5. Born To Make You Happy vs. Come On Over (All I Want Is You)
6. From The Bottom Of My Broken Heart vs. Reflection 
7. I Will Be There vs. Love For All Seasons
8. I Will Still Love You vs. Somebody's Somebody
9. Deep In My Heart vs. When You Put Your Hands On Me
10. Thinkin' About You vs. Blessed 
11. E-Mail My Heart vs. Love Will Find A Way
12. The Beat Goes On vs. Obvious

Who had the better debut album?

Brenda. But i can't stand both debut singles in nowdays.......and Xtina has boring songs in her debut. So much "modern" as it's annoying and soulless. 

[Wendy Williams]

6 minutes ago, rik said:

Garlic Kisses  by Jessica Simpson 

I smell your comment
It makes me cry

 

[lane j.]

Tough one, both classic pop albums. I'll list my faves on each and whoever has more wins...

BOMT:

BOMT, Crazy, Sometimes, Born To Make You Happy, From the Bottom of My Broken Heart, Autumn Goodbye

CA:

Genie In A Bottle, What A Girl Wants, Come On Over, I Turn To You, Reflection, Love For All Seasons, Love Will Find A Way

Xtina takes the edge, even though it's the only album I like from her. 

[Oprah Winfrey.]

The one with a Grammy Nigel 

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

1. Radar

2. Radar

3. Radar

4. Radar

5. Radar

6. Radar

7. Radar

8. Radar

9. Radar

10. Radar

11. Radar

12. Radar

She’s that bit ch and you know it