RS released the 200 Greatest Singers of All Time list - Britney's not on it (Update: RS replies)

[Bigno]

I am not.one to trash on others, but are you telling me Taylor friggin Swift is a better vocalist than Celine? For gad sakes! What are they on? Ridiculous. Aguilera is better than Clarkson? Hahahaha what?

Edited January 2, 2023 by Bigno

[Wendy Williams]

17 minutes ago, aoki.loid said:

& billie eyelish is on this list 

Who 

[Wendy Williams]

8 minutes ago, Bigno said:

I am not.one to trash on others, but are you telling me Taylor friggin Swift is a better vocalist than Celine? For gad sakes! What are they on? Ridiculous. Aguilera is better than Clarckson? Hahahaha what?

There is also Taylor?

[Mr. AmericanDream]

I mean did we REALLY thing Brit was gonna be on that list, cmon. and that's absolutely NO shade cuz I'll throw hands for my girl all day. MJ also didn't make the cut and that's FATHA to half those heaux's on the list. 

[rik]

3 hours ago, Neydelinska Spearsi said:

 

People like Billie Eilish shouldn't even be on that list. If her whispering is considered singing, I'm done

Fk u @Blackout2006, ur fav is tired and cancelled and for Christ’s sake plz stop paying press for billes promo. Olive rogers replaced her, us Gen z decided that remember. @CrazyButItFeelsAllright plz ban this puta for her reductive taste in whisper pop 

Topic followed

Edited January 2, 2023 by Rik vs Exhale

[Bigno]

6 hours ago, BananaBoy98 said:

There is also Taylor?

Yes, at 102. I also think not putting MJ is sacrilege.

I would not have expected Britney here, but Swift...

Edited January 2, 2023 by Bigno

[RadicalOptimism]

47 minutes ago, Rik vs Exhale said:

Fk u @Blackout2006, ur fav is tired and cancelled and for Christ’s sake plz stop paying press for billes promo. Olive rogers replaced her, us Gen z decided that remember. @CrazyButItFeelsAllright plz ban this puta for her reductive taste in whisper pop 

Topic followed

My man is a Billie stan and out of respect for his fave I would like to be excluded from this convo  

[rik]

6 minutes ago, CrazyButItFeelsAllright said:

My man is a Billie stan and out of respect for his fave I would like to be excluded from this convo  

OMF so sorry for u

[brymo]

I was really okay with it until I saw Rihanna at 68. Seriously?

[JP9101]

3 hours ago, ObsessedBritFan1 said:

That rehearsal is iconic 

[RadicalOptimism]

36 minutes ago, Rik vs Exhale said:

OMF so sorry for u

I made him a Dua stan and we met at Piece of Me so the fact he was already a Britney stan is enough for me to forgive his other faves (which I used to Stan btw before @Blackout2006 overexposed her on Exhale back in 2020 )

[Eternalhouse]

I don't mind Britney not being in the list cuz there are so many fabulous singers in the world.

But Taylor over Kelly Clarkson or Brandy.....

Something must have gone so very wrong in the parallel universe. Cuz this does not make sense in the world I live in now.

 

[ZoneGirl]

I just don't understand the logic in putting Taylor Can't Sing Swift on the list and not including Britney, who has a distinct voice despite not being a strong vocalist. Taylor Swift is like Bob Dylan. Great songwriters. Not good singers.

Edited January 2, 2023 by ZoneGirl

[xpiritualism]

why does this fanbase need validation from RollingStones?

It's just the opinion of useless journalists 

there's no way for anyone to assign a definite value to any piece of music, or any artist really, because music means different things to different people

i hate music critics  

Edited January 2, 2023 by xpiritualism

[kissit]

michael jacksons not on there lol 👋🏽✌🏽 byee. and britneys underrated. her voice is so iconic but also she was on star search before. a vocal competition show

[gar]

I mean, Dylan's barely a singer at all, let alone a great one.

[Heyyallzes]

9 hours ago, Emil87 said:

She sang well enough to become the biggest female popstar in music history… 

You don’t have to be a (good) singer to become a big Popstar. Madonna and Britney both proofed that

Edited January 2, 2023 by britneybits2022

[SosEtaSeth]

10 hours ago, Neydelinska Spearsi said:

 

People like Billie Eilish shouldn't even be on that list. If her whispering is considered singing, I'm done

Or Olivia Rodrigo. God, that's one talentless hack if I've ever seen one.

[Stannedforever]

Does anyone take RS seriously nowadays. They only write articles to please their readers aka the music elitists.

[Catalin]

10 hours ago, CrazyButItFeelsAllright said:

Why did I know Beyoncé’s overrated *** was going to be in the top ten 

At this point, I'm just surprised she isn't at #1. l