Gaga called "Artpop" one of her most critically acclaimed albums

[Borja]

Every time I listen to it I skip like 10 songs lol

I like the singles and Gypsy, that in my opinion is one of her best songs ever, but overall it's not a good album... don't be delusional.

[The Pink Sheep]

I played this album so much I got skinny at one point definitely one of my favorite Gaga albums. It's so fun to dance to and just have a good time. Don't get the hate. 

Donatella is still that bop. Wish I dropped Molly to this 

[Oxic]

But did she really said that? On 10:40 she said it was a heavily scrutinized album

 

 

[AndyFoster]

To me, it’s along the same lines of Bionic. People still don't know whether it was ahead of its time and is brilliant, or whether it is utter garbage. 

[I Always Sing Live]

Artpop is freakin' awesome. I listened to it the other day, and I was blown away by how good it is because I hadn't listened to it in a hot minute. Moreover, I added the Christina version of Do What U Want to the tracklist, since the R-pe Kelly one isn't available anymore. I mean, good riddance, but it still has him credited as a writer, so it doesn't change much. Jewels 'n' ***** is the only song I'd have scrapped, though it's not even bad - it just doesn't really add anything to the album. Maybe Mary Jane Holland, but it kinda slaps, tbh.

[bitbitboi]

3 hours ago, Spicechinodiva said:

Donatella has the best lyrics our girls can relate..

 

"Just ask your gay friends for their advice, before you get a tan in st. Tropez"

 

"I'm the rich *****, I'm the upper class, I eat and some and drink Chapagne"

 

"I'll wear designer and forget your name"

That's not gay, that's c u n t.

[gapeach704]

Sorry but no. After TFM, her albums as a whole have been trash, aside from 4-5 songs on each. Chromatica was her worst album yet. Although I want Britney to cover “Free Woman” one of these days tbh 

[Whyshouldibsad21]

***xx Dreams was good, do what u want was alright…the rest were throw away to me. Go awf tho Gaga, toot ur horn girl. 

[Justin Woodpond]

1 hour ago, AndyFoster said:

To me, it’s along the same lines of Bionic. People still don't know whether it was ahead of its time and is brilliant, or whether it is utter garbage. 

It’s definitely not ahead of it’s time.

There’s nothing innovative or unique about it.

[Spicechinodiva]

4 hours ago, Oxic said:

But did she really said that? On 10:40 she said it was a heavily scrutinized album

 

 

Well it was and many of the reviews wasn't reviews, but reviews on her personal life, and some critics pointed that out. 

As one reviewer for Forbes said.

 

"It's a miracle anybody can hear the music, with the knifes sharpening at gaga and being held to her"

@Jordan Miller

[Alestaos]

17 hours ago, UncannyX-Man2099 said:

 

A few good songs, but a forgettable and dated album. 

I only liked G.U.Y

[Stefani]

More acclaimed by stans in recent years maybe, but as far as I know no official publications have gone back and re-assessed the album or given it a higher rating. That said, she's right that when the album first came out a bunch of reviewers focused more on criticizing her than on critiquing the music itself. 

[babyimmafreak90]

4 hours ago, I Always Sing Live said:

Artpop is freakin' awesome. I listened to it the other day, and I was blown away by how good it is because I hadn't listened to it in a hot minute. Moreover, I added the Christina version of Do What U Want to the tracklist, since the R-pe Kelly one isn't available anymore. I mean, good riddance, but it still has him credited as a writer, so it doesn't change much. Jewels 'n' ***** is the only song I'd have scrapped, though it's not even bad - it just doesn't really add anything to the album. Maybe Mary Jane Holland, but it kinda slaps, tbh.

Jewels ‘n’ ***** is the only song I’ve skipped since the first time I’ve heard it. Peak cringe imo. Mary Jane Holland is a grower and a total vibe. For me, Artpop is better as an album than its individual songs. Though Venus deserved way better than and intro song in a MV. 

[Alestaos]

10 minutes ago, Stefani said:

More acclaimed by stans in recent years maybe, but as far as I know no official publications have gone back and re-assessed the album or given it a higher rating. That said, she's right that when the album first came out a bunch of reviewers focused more on criticizing her than on critiquing the music itself. 

Unfortunately this happens with popular stars, even Britney and Christina encountered this during their prime.

Terrible practice

[Isla]

I actually really like ARTPOP and think it's a solid pop album. I love the experimentation in the tracks. However, I think it's only really critically acclaimed among Gaga fans (and maybe some general pop music fans). It deffo deserved better at the time of its release though.

[Isla]

4 hours ago, Oxic said:

But did she really said that? On 10:40 she said it was a heavily scrutinized album

 

 

Well the OP linked to Gaga's latest interview with the New York Times, where she spoke about this.

[Midnight]

35 minutes ago, Isla said:

Well the OP linked to Gaga's latest interview with the New York Times, where she spoke about this.

Yes this and it's actually a really interesting read.

[bitbitboi]

5 hours ago, AndyFoster said:

To me, it’s along the same lines of Bionic. People still don't know whether it was ahead of its time and is brilliant, or whether it is utter garbage. 

Why do the gays keep repeating that thing about "Bionic" being ahead of its time? Maybe Xtina meant it production-wise, but what is the value in that if THE SONGS AND HER SINGING WERE A COMPLETE MIMIC OF THE ARTISTS SHE COLLABORATED WITH?? She totally lost her personality in that record. As if she were half a robot. Exactly like in the cover for the album. It's like that false advertising for products that are not particularly good for the health but still they are promoted saying things like "IT HAS NO FAT" but it's ridiculously high in sugar or it has no fibre at all when it should. Same thing.

[bitbitboi]

40 minutes ago, Isla said:

I actually really like ARTPOP and think it's a solid pop album. I love the experimentation in the tracks. However, I think it's only really critically acclaimed among Gaga fans (and maybe some general pop music fans). It deffo deserved better at the time of its release though.

I guess all fan bases need their "incredibly underrated album by the public and the critics" 

Gaga already has "Born This Way", and Xtina "Stripped", but since those two are already considered good albums, fans have to dig deeper to stay hip, I guess...

[S0ggyBiscuit]

18 hours ago, S0ggyBiscuit said:

So whose going to tell her...

 

ARTPOP is a bop tho.