Your Favorite Artists' Discography Tier List

[ALBAVEASP]

To continue the tier list thread, let's dive in to our favorite artists' discography. Just follow the instructions, rules and my examples, you're good to go.

Descriptions:

Spoiler

Pop Supreme : a seemingly flawless album.
Greatness : has few issues here and there, but still a top notch record.
Just Right : despite having noticeable flaws, the highlights make the album above average.
Mixed Bag : more like a 50/50 record, it's not good, but not bad either.
Underwhelming : the issues are way more prominent than the album itself.
Shelf It : the record's production and lyrical qualities sound short and rushed.

Rules:

Spoiler

1. The original date of release must be indicated after the record's name; Happier Than Ever (2021).
2. Reissues, extended plays, compilation and live albums are not included.

Template:

Spoiler

(Artist's Name)

Pop Supreme : 
Greatness : 
Just Right : 
Mixed Bag : 
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

 

Example 1:

Blur

Pop Supreme : The Great Escape (1995)
Greatness : Parklife (1994) • 13 (1999)
Just Right : Leisure (1991) • Modern Life Is Rubbish (1993) • Blur (1997) • The Magic Whip (2015)
Mixed Bag : Think Tank (2003)
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

 

Example 2:

Katy Perry

Pop Supreme : PRISM (2013)
Greatness : Teenage Dream (2010)
Just Right : One Of The Boys (2008)
Mixed Bag : Katy Hudson (2001) • Witness (2017) • Smile (2020)
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

 

Spoiler

Happy Pride Month, everyone! 

Yours?

Edited June 5, 2021 by Midnight

[ALBAVEASP]

Ariana Grande-Gomez

Pop Supreme : 
Greatness : Sweetener (2018) • thank u, next (2019)
Just Right : Yours Truly (2013) • Dangerous Woman (2016)
Mixed Bag : My Everything (2014)
Underwhelming : Positions (2020)
Shelf It : 

[Look But Don't Touch]

2 hours ago, ALBAVEASP said:

Ariana Grande-Gomez

Not Ariana Grande-Gomez 

[redacted statement]

Olivia Rodrigo

• Pop Supreme: Sour (2021)
• Greatness: 
• Just Right: 
• Mixed Bag: 
• Underwhelming: 
• Shelf It: 

[redacted statement]

Carly Rae Jepsen

• Pop Supreme: E·MO·TION (2015) 💞 E·MO·TION : Side B (2016) 💞 Dedicated (2019) 💞 Dedicated : Side B (2020)
• Greatness: Tug of War (2008)
• Just Right: Kiss (2012)
• Mixed Bag: 
• Underwhelming: 
• Shelf It: 

[JSDSandiego]

 

Pop Supreme :  Piece By Piece, Breakaway, All I ever Wanted
Greatness : Meaning of Life, Stronger, Wrapped in Red
Just Right : Thankful, My December
Mixed Bag : 
Underwhelming :
Shelf It : 

[Isla]

Lady Gaga

Pop Supreme : The Fame Monster
Greatness : ARTPOP, Chromatica
Just Right : The Fame, Born This Way, Joanne

[Mexwero]

 

Adele

Pop Supreme : 21 (2011), Carpool Karaoke (Rapping Nicki’s ‘Monster’ verse) 🤣🤣
Greatness : 25 (2015), 19 (2008) 
Just Right : 
Mixed Bag : 
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

[ALBAVEASP]

6 hours ago, iAlwaysSingLive said:

Olivia Rodrigo

• Pop Supreme: Sour (2021)
• Greatness: 
• Just Right: 
• Mixed Bag: 
• Underwhelming: 
• Shelf It: 

[CHAOTIC STYLE.]

Onika Tanya Maraj

• Pop Supreme: The Pinkprint (2014), Queen (2018). 
• Greatness: Pink Friday (2010), Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded (2012). 

#HappyPrideMonth🌈🎀🦄

[hybirdfox]

SHAKIRA

Pop Supreme : Donde Estan Los Ladrones, Laundry Service
Greatness : Oral Fixation, Shakira, El Dorado
Just Right : Pies Descalzos, Fijacion Oral, Sale El Sol
Mixed Bag : Magia, Peligro
Underwhelming : She Wolf
Shelf It :

[Adriannn]

TAYLOR SWIFT

Pop Supreme : Red (2012) 1989 (2014) Reputation (2017) Folklore (2020)
Greatness : Speak Now (2010) Evermore (2020) Fearless Taylor’s Version (2021)
Just Right : Fearless (2008) Lover (2019)
Mixed Bag : Taylor Swift (2006)
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

[boyinthemirror]

This is fun

Britney Spears

Pop Supreme : Britney, In The Zone, Blackout, Circus
Greatness : Oops!...I Did It Again, ...Baby One More Time, Glory, Femme Fatale
Mixed Bag : Britney Jean

Christina Aguilera

Pop Supreme : Stripped, Bionic, Back to Basics
Greatness : Christina Aguilera, Liberation
Just Right : Lotus, Mi Reflejo

Aaliyah

Pop Supreme : Aaliyah, One in a Million
Greatness : Age Ain't Nothing but a Number

JoJo

Pop Supreme : Agápē, Can't Take That Away from Me, The High Road
Greatness : good to know, JoJo
Just Right : Mad Love

Utada Hikaru

Pop Supreme : Ultra Blue, Deep River, Exodus
Greatness : Distance, Fantôme, Hatsukoi, HEART STATION
Just Right : First Love, This Is The One
Mixed Bag : Precious

Usher

Pop Supreme : 8701, Confessions, My Way
Greatness : Here I Stand, Looking 4 Myself
Just Right : Raymond v Raymond
Mixed Bag : Usher
Underwhelming : Hard II Love
Shelf It : "A"

Nelly Furtado

Pop Supreme : Folklore, Loose, The Ride
Greatness : The Spirit Indestructible
Just Right : Whoa, Nelly!, Mi Plan

Shakira

Pop Supreme : Dónde Están Los Ladrones?, Fijación Oral Vol. 1
Greatness : Oral Fixation Vol. 2, Laundry Service, Pies Descalzos, She Wolf
Just Right : Sale el Sol, Shakira., El Dorado
Mixed Bag : Magia
Underwhelming : Peligro

[Popcornie]

Avril Lavigne

Pop Supreme : Under My Skin, TBDT
Greatness : Let Go
Just Right : Avril Lavigne
Mixed Bag : Goodbye Lullaby, Head Above Water
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

Taylor Swift

Pop Supreme : Speak Now, Red, 1989, folklore
Greatness : Fearless, reputation, Lover, evermore
Just Right : 
Mixed Bag : Taylor Swift
Underwhelming : 
Shelf It : 

 

Kylie Minogue

Pop Supreme : Fever, Aphrodite
Greatness : Light Years, Body Language, X, Disco
Just Right : Kylie Minogue, Impossible Princess
Mixed Bag : Rhytm Of Love, Enjoy Yourself, Golden
Underwhelming : Kylie, Kiss Me Once

Shelf It : Lets Get To It

[ALBAVEASP]

2 hours ago, Adriannn said:

 

TAYLOR SWIFT

Just Right : Fearless (2008)
 

[ALBAVEASP]

1 hour ago, boyinthemirror said:

Shakira

Pop Supreme : Dónde Están Los Ladrones?, Fijación Oral Vol. 1
Greatness : Oral Fixation Vol. 2, Laundry Service, Pies Descalzos, She Wolf
Just Right : Sale el Sol, Shakira., El Dorado
Mixed Bag : Magia
Underwhelming : Peligro

[ALBAVEASP]

6 hours ago, hybirdfox said:

SHAKIRA

Underwhelming : She Wolf

[Hooked-On-Knee]

Britney Spears

Pop Supreme : Oops!...I Did It Again (2000), Britney (2001), In the Zone (2003)
Greatness : Circus (2008), Glory (2016), Blackout (2007)
Just Right : ...Baby One More Time (1999)
Mixed Bag : 
Underwhelming : Femme Fatale (2011)
Shelf It : Britney Jean (2013)

[jordeezy river red]

3 minutes ago, Hooked-On-Knee said:

Britney Spears

Pop Supreme : Oops!...I Did It Again (2000), Britney (2001), In the Zone (2003)
Greatness : Circus (2008), Glory (2016), Blackout (2007)
Just Right : ...Baby One More Time (1999)
Mixed Bag : 
Underwhelming : Femme Fatale (2011)
Shelf It : Britney Jean (2013)

FF deserves to be "Just Right" but I agree with your others 

[Popcornie]

Xtina

 

Pop Supreme : Stripped, Back To Basics
Greatness : Bionic
Just Right : Christina Aguilera
Mixed Bag : Liberation
Underwhelming : Lotus
Shelf It :