Why did Hold Me Closer chart and Gaga's Elton assisted song did not?

[Body ache]

 

[britney_rocks]

[Donavan Ward]

Britney loves Gaga and Gaga loves Britney and Gaga fans love Britney….grow up 

[Almost Mystical]

I'm so happy Britney made us cocky again. 

[Kletus]

Because God Me Closer is a good song

[jamesedward94]

bc it wasn’t a single

which is a CRIME bc it deserved to be and have a music video!

[Almost Mystical]

1 hour ago, jamesedward94 said:

bc it wasn’t a single

which is a CRIME bc it deserved to be and have a music video!

Probably the label refuse to finance the video because it didn't do that well.

[DontNeedAReasonWhy]

3 hours ago, Body ache said:

 

Good song though but maybe next year it’s hold me closer time 

[super.nova]

because tiny dancer is one of the most iconic songs ever

[Greg Sargent]

[Princessmimi]

Cause Britney still has giant star power.

NOT saying Gaga doesnt have any but

I also do think that HMC charted higher cause it was deemed as Britney's "comeback song".

[Body ache]

2 hours ago, jamesedward94 said:

bc it wasn’t a single

which is a CRIME bc it deserved to be and have a music video!

It was on a commercial that was everywhere and it still didn't chart.

[Almost Mystical]

It’s pretty simple actually. Because Britney know how to make a pop song works. No offense for Gaga but sometimes, including this song is a bit too overproduced that it just noise. It’s the whole feeling that goes to BPM, chorus to be repeated, break placement. Britney know what works and what doesn’t. 

[Canada4286]

I could be wrong.. but I believe it has something to do with Britney not releasing music in 6 years, as well as the freebritney movement giving her mainstream attention. Again, not an expert so don't cuss me out 

[Arthurfleck]

Britney’s charisma, talent and momentum >>>> all other pop girls sweating and working like crazy

[Jordan Miller]

13 hours ago, jamesedward94 said:

bc it wasn’t a single

which is a CRIME bc it deserved to be and have a music video!

[Endlessstan]

Promo…??? 

[jordeezy river red]

Chromatica as a whole was so disappointing. Way too polished to be a Gaga album, felt more like Ava Max. 

[Mr. Cavill]

14 hours ago, jamesedward94 said:

bc it wasn’t a single

which is a CRIME bc it deserved to be and have a music video!

This.

Sine from above is a wonderful song and my personal highlight from Chromatica. They should've recorded a music video, though I remember rumours that there was one on its way but Gaga forgot about Chromatica, just like Artpop. 

[bitbitboi]

... because SFA wasn't a single and because people were / are stupid towards Chromatica, an amazing album overall 

HMC is superior though, because Britney is a bigger star. Period.