Britney vs Xtina singing at a young age

[e-mailmyheart]

We all know that nowadays who has the best voice is Christina Aguilera, Britney herself said that she loved to have a voice like hers, but in their childhood? I think in terms of voice Britney was at the level of Christina and I think she had better presence on stage and more charisma.

What do you think?
 

[none]

where's the 2017 comparison ?  

[e-mailmyheart]

44 minutes ago, Dark.Knight said:

where's the 2017 comparison ?  

The title says at a young age, because at this time her voice could compete with Christina's. 

[3Pney]

45 minutes ago, Dark.Knight said:

where's the 2017 comparison ?  

theres none cuz nobody remembers xtina and she doesnt have any live shows anymore. poor her. 

[Noname2022]

3 minutes ago, 3Pney said:

theres none cuz nobody remembers xtina and she doesnt have any live shows anymore. poor her. 

Britney also doesn't have any 'live' shows. 

 

Btw, I think Britney's voice was better back then. She had more power and control. Xtine's voice was all over the place and very 'scratchy'. It didn't change much tbh. But Britney had so much potential to be on par with the best singers of today, but she ruined it

[InTheZone4U]

Ugh I wish Britney would have fought for her voice!! Yes the baby voice made her but Britney auditioned singing this way which means she wanted to sing and be known as a singer not a 'singer'...  if only she could have had her uptempo hits and also be able to have those great ballads during her career... 

 

[The Greatest Show]

I think when they were very young Britny had a better voice but around MMC Christina cought up and finally learned to control her voice.  Her I have nothing performance from then was amazing.

[Britneybbhmm]

Whoa Brinny!

That's my guuurl! <3

[celebration2009]

RIP headphone users

[PokemonSpears]

[troubleguy]

but in the end, it doesn't even matter  where is brit wheres xtina now?

[e-mailmyheart]

7 minutes ago, Pedro Dantas said:

RIP headphone users

 What headphone users have to do with this topic?

[Iexpectyouto]

britney had such a great voice. such a shame. at the time she had much more control of her voice. beautiful 

[Guest StrawberryKisses]

They're both different when deeper. Christina is more melodic, whilst Britney is straight to the point.

[britisthecolor]

yeah britney sounded as good as christina when they were children/teenagers but to me it sounds like britney had to force herself more than christina in order to sing good.

[3Pney]

8 hours ago, brintyjoan said:

Britney also doesn't have any 'live' shows. 

 

Britney always sings live tho 

[Britneylandia]

9 hours ago, borogroves said:

sis where have you been? her voice hasn't change since  1998

That's only because when haven't heard her voice since 1998 

[none]

8 hours ago, e-mailmyheart said:

 What headphone users have to do with this topic?

...that those wearing headphones will be affected due to the volume of the video