Who is more of an icon? Lady Gaga or Beyoncé

[descg]

19 hours ago, GODNA IS A QUEEN said:

If we’re solely talking icon status, it’s Beyoncé  Gaga. If we’re talking about who had the most impressive peak moments, it’s Gaga Beyonce.

For me is more like this.

[descg]

There are another things about Britney comparing to Gaga or Beyonce that they have done her more Legend than the music:

- Being a white blonde with pretty face girl (dont misinterpret i dont say that is right, or my opinion for being more iconic, but things in society were like were) she was like the 90's/00's Marilyn in therms of physic (and in others therms more later).

- More interest/controversy in her personal life or even artistry.

For me in that list that the user "GODNA IS A QUEEN" none is a Legend, there some icons and depends de for who or where are you live (Legends are The Beatles, Elvis, Freddie Mercury, Madonna... Maybe Abba, George Michael, Prince, 2pac, Biggie, Aaliyah, even Britney):

Britney, JLo, maybe Christina (is my favorite but im honest has lost impact), Beyoncé, Amy (not only because the music saddly, Rihanna, Gaga, Adele (maybe), Lana (more like creating new style).

About Taylor (shes too local, here in Spain not many people care).

[stanLOONA]

Neither 

I do have to point that Beyoncé gives me "legend" status tho~

[Wendy Williams]

7 hours ago, screamurlungsout said:

lady gaga has more hits, more iconic moments and performances 

the fame monster alone is better and way more memorable than beyoncé’s entire discography 

argue w yourselves 

 

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

Yoncé..   

[petermaxforreal]

Both are not equally iconic 

[rik]

2 hours ago, stanLOONA said:

Neither 

I do have to point that Beyoncé gives me "legend" status tho~

But even in u not caring about either you are aware beyonce is a legend omfg 

[breathe_on_me_toxic]

gaga oh ohh

[princessmimi]

Lady Gaga for sure

[DignifiedLove]

On 8/21/2022 at 8:25 AM, descg said:

For me is more like this.

That doesn’t make any sense considering that Gaga had one of the highest peaks of all time for a female solo act from 2009-11. Beyoncé never had a peak like Gaga (or Britney) but she maintained more longevity and that alone makes her more of an icon than Gaga. The fact that she just released her 7th studio album with the #1 song and album in the country while breaking countless other records is very telling of her relevancy at this given moment. Do your research. 

[BrittonJeanSpears]

Gaga. I mean, look at the meat dress! The bubble dress! Name one Beyonce moment that compares in impact.

[Mmdellavecchia]

I prefer Gaga but Beyoncé.

[OneLife]

They are both amazing singers... but undoubtedly Beyonce, a longer career... the difficulty is not to succeed big once but to maintain the career for decades..

[GlitterRain]

Just now, OneLife said:

They are both amazing singers... but undoubtedly Beyonce, a longer career... the difficulty is not to succeed big once but to maintain the career for decades..

[descg]

2 hours ago, GODNA IS A QUEEN said:

That doesn’t make any sense considering that Gaga had one of the highest peaks of all time for a female solo act from 2009-11. Beyoncé never had a peak like Gaga (or Britney) but she maintained more longevity and that alone makes her more of an icon than Gaga. The fact that she just released her 7th studio album with the #1 song and album in the country while breaking countless other records is very telling of her relevancy at this given moment. Do your research. 

Crazy In Love Or Single Ladies (even Say My Name) singles releases are very hard peaks, but i said "more like this", no "is the total oposite".

[DignifiedLove]

1 hour ago, descg said:

Crazy In Love Or Single Ladies (even Say My Name) singles releases are very hard peaks, but i said "more like this", no "is the total oposite".

“The Fame/The Fame Monster” and “Born This Way” eras were objectively bigger than “Dangerously in Love” and “I Am Sasha Fierce”, or any Destiny’s Child era for that matter. Again, Gaga had a larger tsunami level peak but Beyoncé had more longevity.

[rik]

Just now, GODNA IS A QUEEN said:

“The Fame/The Fame Monster” and “Born This Way” eras were objectively bigger than “Dangerously in Love” and “I Am Sasha Fierce”, or any Destiny’s Child era for that matter. Again, Gaga had a larger peak than Beyoncé.

Janet outsold both

 

[DignifiedLove]

1 minute ago, Future Nostalgia said:

Janet outsold both

 

And Shania outdid them all 

[rik]

Just now, GODNA IS A QUEEN said:

And Shania outdid them all 

Actually that was Willa

She should’ve performed at the 2016 VMAs instead of B and B imagine what she could do with that stage 

[GlitterRain]

1 minute ago, Future Nostalgia said:

Actually that was Willa

She should’ve performed at the 2016 VMAs instead of B and B imagine what she could do with that stage 

Queen Willa!!