Love Story vs Umbrella

[countrymusiccritic]

 

 

 

Two hugely iconic hit singles that are still beloved to this day. Better song?

[DignifiedLove]

Umbrella for literally all 4

Edit: Not a fan of Taylor Swift but I can’t deny that ‘Love Story’ is an amazing song. I think I like Umbrella more by a slight edge but LS is very close and it gives me a lot of memories.

[anthony7226]

Apples to oranges. This is not a fair fight. I voted based off of quality and musicianship. Love Story gets the Better Song vote because of it's authenticity, orginality, depth and range. Umbrella is staight up Pop/R&B royalty so it deserves a lot of vote, but next to Love Story it loses out in that context. It does get the More Classic vote though cause aint nobody out there that won't accidentally hum this song for hours at the mere mention of an umbrella. Umbrella vs. Promiscuous would be better, Love Story vs. Before He Cheats would be better.

[CHAOTIC STYLE.]

Love God and God’s Story is the only right answer. 

[Adriannn]

Ok this one is a bit odd... 

I love Taylor, and while Love Story is a classic, Umbrella has owned my heart since 2007. To my dismay, Rih Rih sang just half of it during the Anti World Tour... we stan a lazy queen 

[CHAOTIC STYLE.]

1 minute ago, Adriannn said:

Ok this one is a bit odd... 

I love Taylor, and while Love Story is a classic, Umbrella has owned my heart since 2007. To my dismay, Rih Rih sang just half of it during the Anti World Tour... we stan a lazy queen 

Knot on my watch, king 

[Adriannn]

1 minute ago, Style. said:

Knot on my watch, king 

[CHAOTIC STYLE.]

3 minutes ago, Adriannn said:

Romeo take me where we can be alone, it’s a love story baby just say yes 

[Adriannn]

31 minutes ago, Style. said:

Romeo take me where we can be alone, it’s a love story baby just say yes 

wondering if you would ever come here around 

or coming around? 

[Jordan Miller]

Ughhh can't choose! Umbrella then

[blackoutbixxh]

Umbrella 

[Bigno]

Love Story is everything I disliked about Taylor for so long, boring and bland. I totally lost her from my radar until 1989. Umbrella all the way. 

[Moscow]

Umbrella clears with ease! Though Love story is a WW hit. 

[Alexanda]

LoveStory is not a top 20 hit where i'm from and Umbrella dominated the radio and charts. So: Umbrella.