Myahs voice in Circus

[Alexanda]

Like

Why? 

 

[richluv0715]

The second one (lower voice) is definitely Britney. 

The higher, I've always thought sounded like muah. But hearing it like this sounds like it's Britney. Just edited/manipulated higher 

[Buffybot]

I understand Britney Jean was a terrible situation and even I have some doubts nowadays what's really Britney or not, but we only know for sure the "replacement" scandal happened during that era.

Myah did backing vocals for circus and FF albums. I'm saying this because i've seen some haters spreading lies about Britney not singing some songs from others albums. Like Keri Hilson supposedly sang for Britney because we can hear her on GM and BTI... Or that Cathy Dennis is the real Toxic singer. 

I know Myah story will always haunt us, but some fans exaggerates with these videos without any proof.

[Stannedforever]

I mean, circus stems leaked few years ago and there's like 8 bg vocal tracks which each have multiple vocals layered so yeah there's a lot of Britney mixed with Cathy Dennis, Myah Marie and Claude Kelly 

[Brit Brit]

Eh, I don't see the big deal. To be honest, I always assumed most of the vocals on Circus album was Britney, because this 'vocal double' controversy wasn't a thing really until BJ era.

There's a difference between simply providing background vocals (like Victoria Monet does for Ariana) and then there's vocals that 'they' try to disguise as Britney's vocals (i.e. BJ era songs). What Myah is doing here is simply singing background. Not everything has to be questioned in Britney's music post-Blackout. Where was this energy when Keri Hilson sung background vocals on the Blackout album?

[Blackout2006]

10 minutes ago, Brit Brit said:

Eh, I don't see the big deal. To be honest, I always assumed most of the vocals on Circus album was Britney, because this 'vocal double' controversy wasn't a thing really until BJ era.

There's a difference between simply providing background vocals (like Victoria Monet does for Ariana) and then there's vocals that 'they' try to disguise as Britney's vocals (i.e. BJ era songs). What Myah is doing here is simply singing background. Not everything has to be questioned in Britney's music post-Blackout. Where was this energy when Keri Hilson sung background vocals on the Blackout album?

[Hypnotherapy]

Yeah i remember this came out a while ago after Simon Ellis did a Circus remix using Brit’s vocals. I think it’s different in that they’re not disguising Myah as Britney here, she is in the track, just layered, they haven’t cut and paste Myah into lead.

This is more like the chorus in TTWE, HATLM, the heavy layering in her early songs like Oops and Baby etc 

The weird thing is, maybe I’m biased but I prefer her moodier deep stems for Circus and HATLM than the BGV super high pitched singing. Wish they’d have more faith that fans of Brit like HER voice even if it’s not doing vocal cartwheels.

[girl_bye]

another day another myah thread...

[Stan2092]

OMG! The second part is amazing!

Sounds like Myah. She's background vocalist. It's ok, isn't?

[Lonely2001]

Yes, you can hear her vocals, but only as a background singer. As a lead singer imo this is her percentage on Britney Jean:

- Alien 40%

- Work Work 100%

- Perfume 0%

- It Should Be Easy 20%

- Tik Tik Boom 40%

- Body Ache 100%

- Til It's Gone 100%

- Passenger 90%

- Chillin with Lou 100%

- Don't Cry 0%

- Brughtest Morning Star 50%

- Hold On Tight 20%

- Now That I Found You 50%

And that's all. She didn't sung any leads on Circus or FF. She did the background vocals.

[Easy There]

Myah did background vocals on Circus. Aka the thing she was hired to do so.

There is literally 10 vocal layers on it. More than half is Britney harmonizing with herself. 

[Arckangel]

14 hours ago, Lonely2001 said:

Yes, you can hear her vocals, but only as a background singer. As a lead singer imo this is her percentage on Britney Jean:

- Alien 40%

- Work Work 100%

- Perfume 0%

- It Should Be Easy 20%

- Tik Tik Boom 40%

- Body Ache 100%

- Til It's Gone 100%

- Passenger 90%

- Chillin with Lou 100%

- Don't Cry 0%

- Brughtest Morning Star 50%

- Hold On Tight 20%

- Now That I Found You 50%

And that's all. She didn't sung any leads on Circus or FF. She did the background vocals.

 

This is more accurate:

 

@rr_174

[Arckangel]

14 hours ago, Stan2092 said:

OMG! The second part is amazing!

Sounds like Myah. She's background vocalist. It's ok, isn't?

The first part is Myah, the second is Brit.

[Arckangel]

19 hours ago, richluv0715 said:

The second one (lower voice) is definitely Britney. 

The higher, I've always thought sounded like muah. But hearing it like this sounds like it's Britney. Just edited/manipulated higher 

The first part is Myah (she's the credited background vocalist).

[Louis-j]

Yeah this is the first time Myah took the lead in a Britney song, but only for that small part.

I say she takes the lead because even if Britney is in there, she's not that audible and you hear Myah only.

[Y2Gay jordeezy]

I always felt like "Phonography" isn't Britney 

[nthenwkiss]

omg that second part is so ****, i love britney's voice, we need to hear her voice more!!! i just remembered how over-edited SITS is.

[Brit Brit]

On 1/28/2021 at 4:38 AM, Lonely2001 said:

Yes, you can hear her vocals, but only as a background singer. As a lead singer imo this is her percentage on Britney Jean:

- Alien 40%

- Work Work 100%

- Perfume 0%

- It Should Be Easy 20%

- Tik Tik Boom 40%

- Body Ache 100%

- Til It's Gone 100%

- Passenger 90%

- Chillin with Lou 100%

- Don't Cry 0%

- Brughtest Morning Star 50%

- Hold On Tight 20%

- Now That I Found You 50%

And that's all. She didn't sung any leads on Circus or FF. She did the background vocals.

Are we sure about Work B, though? I don't think it was 100%. Possibly 50%, but not 100%. The talking/rap parts to me always sounded like Britney, just with a british accent-ish delivery, but we've been used to that since 2006/2007. The singing parts def sound like Myah, or a mixture of both of them.

[Lonely2001]

47 minutes ago, Brit Brit said:

Are we sure about Work B, though? I don't think it was 100%. Possibly 50%, but not 100%. The talking/rap parts to me always sounded like Britney, just with a british accent-ish delivery, but we've been used to that since 2006/2007. The singing parts def sound like Myah, or a mixture of both of them.

I mean I'm not that sure but clearly there is more Myah in that song than Brit.