Selena Gomez's best album?

[Exhale]

Main paged! @Blackout2006 

[Isla]

I'm listening to Stars Dance now and it's not a bad album, lots of bops even if it does sound a bit dated. Although I think I prefer Revival/Rare because both albums are more 'artistic' and show Selena's growth as an artist. But it's not bad.

Which is the best Scene album though, that's the question

[BritneySpurs]

I think her albums get worse lol. I really liked Stars Dance and Revival, I just prefer SD. Rare is just okay. The new songs on the deluxe re-release are better than anything on the actual album but it's still not great imo.

[Midnight]

2 minutes ago, rik said:

***** do u know how old that is.... it's so old that i know it. i bought kiss and tell in 2010 in grade 7

it bored me so much aside from naturally and stop and erase, and i got u

 I got bored too I streamed it I think like two years ago maybe ? I couldn't, I tried, I gave her a chance and it just didn't work. At least we can agree that stop and erase was memorable right ? 

[Blackout2006]

12 hours ago, Exhale said:

Main paged! @Blackout2006 

Awwww why thank you 

[Trent]

Rare > Revival > Stars Dance > When the Sun Goes Down > Kiss & Tell > A Year Without Rain

[Roxxy]

Just now, Trent said:

Rare > Revival > Stars Dance > When the Sun Goes Down > Kiss & Tell > A Year Without Rain

Ooh! Almost accurate! Switch SD and WTSGD and you got it. 

Congratulations for making your first post @Trent ! ❤

Come to post your Selena album ranking, stay for the community!

[F.a.u.zish]

When The Sun Goes Down, to be quite honest with you.

[Blackout2006]

I honestly really like rare because of its quality and unfinished aesthetic of it adds a really nice layer

[MrPieceOfMe]

My favorite is Rare. I just love every track from the album and I never skip any track from it. Also the songs are really smooth and vibe. 

[hybirdfox]

I go with “Stars Dance” the whole album gives me so much ITZ teas. The bonus track (Nobody Does It Like You & Music Feels Better) are flawless

[Blackout2006]

Don’t try discredit rare 

[MX3]

I loved both Rare and Revival. 

But I voted for Stars Dance ...it came out the summer of 2013 and it was such a fun summer and I listened to that album a lot. It has a lot of good memories attached. 

[princessmimi]

Idk why but I consider her 'The Scene' albums as hers since it was basically her singing with a backup band.

I love Revival, I think its her best work and her at her peak.

Everything about it was perfect from the singles, the ballads and her look. (This was also her at her sexiest!)

So yeah I DEFINITELY vote for Revival

[CHAOTIC STYLE.]

Fetish could have been her best if she really went with that vibe. 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Rare and Revival were cute, but not “best” worthy. 

[outrageous122]

#1 REVIVAL - for me she finally arrived with Revival. I always liked her before but I couldn't deny anything on Revival. Revival is a mood, issa vibe.

#2 Rare - it took me a little longer to fully appreciate Rare. With REVIVAL it was instant but Rare is definitely a grower not a shower.

#3 Stars Dance - was cute with a few bangers and stand out tracks but it just wasn't as fully thought out and cohesive as REVIVAL & Rare. (there's a reason she doesn't acknowledge it as SG1 that distinction belongs to REVIVAL)

[BritneyWithGlasses]

glory Revival

[Urbanney]

Her albums always are lukewarm to me.

• Stars Dance was cool when I was a teenager, but now it just sounds like middle school music to me. It didn't age well, it's cheesy and shallow.
• I never really got into Revival as an album in the first place.
• Rare was... weird. I get where she was going with it and it was an empowering breakup album lyrically, but it just sounds weird and doesn't really work for me. I do think the Deluxe version made it better though.

That being said, I almost always love Selena's singles, but I just never strongly enjoy her albums.

[Muzac87]

None. 

[Mainshow]

"Rare" - if we take both deluxe editions into account.