poll Oops!... I Did It Again vs Womanizer

[ILikeChillinWithYou]

Two iconic lead singles both having almost similar views on YouTube- Oops has 227M while Womanizer has 235M. Which one is the better song and video in your opinion and more iconic to their respective eras? 

You know, Thought it'd be really cool and faded to compare them, you know? Very urban and um, very... cool, you know? 

 

 

[Shadow2003]

"Womanizer"'s video is iconic, timeless, still looks great, has an interesting concept and Brandon Stoughton is just...   

"Oops!" is good too, but I prefer "Womanizer" (once again, it's a choice between dance-pop / electropop vs. teen pop / dance-pop, and from some of my previous statements, it should be pretty obvious which one I prefer).

[colormefresh]

Womanizer was a cute moment but Oops is pop history. 

[ILikeChillinWithYou]

1 minute ago, colormefresh said:

Womanizer was a cute moment but Oops is pop history. 

Yes, very Cute

[Menzo]

Oops >>>>>

Video though, maybe Womanizer

[none]

I like Womanizer (song) better

But there's no subjectivity about the Oops video, anyone recognizes that red suit

[Isla]

I think Oops is the better song but Womanizer JUST has a better video. Oops's video is great too though.

[ILikeChillinWithYou]

Yes, as you all say, Oops is iconic. The red catsuit is instantly recognisable, the titular phrase is still used to this day. It's a classic.

But youtube views determine how remembered the song is now by the GP dont they? Why is Womanizer leading by a small margin in that area if Womanizer came nowhere near the icon status as Oops? 

Plus, music wise, Oops sounds dated while Womanizer could still pass off as electro-pop right? 

[redacted statement]

now I want to know which one's the original.. did an editor really have to edit her cameltoe out?? 

[Shadow2003]

 

 

1

4 minutes ago, ILikeChillinWithYou said:

But youtube views determine how remembered the song is now by the GP dont they? Why is Womanizer leading by a small margin in that area if Womanizer came nowhere near the icon status as Oops? 

Maybe it's because people just prefer "Womanizer"'s video... It could be fans just watching it many times because they prefer that one; it doesn't have to be the GP who's responsible for a certain amount of views.

 

 

 

5 minutes ago, ILikeChillinWithYou said:

Plus, music wise, Oops sounds dated while Womanizer could still pass off as electro-pop right? 

I mean, "Womanizer" doesn't even have to 'pass off' as electropop, it's just an electropop song. It doesn't change its genre over time. 

It also came out in 2008, so it definitely sounds fresher than "Oops!". The 'most popular genres' change over time, but electropop is still pretty popular and present in today's hits - take Billie Eilish's "bad guy", for example. It's not gonna be as dated as "Oops!", since that 2000s kind of teen pop is no longer popular or prominent in today's music.

[redacted statement]

while the catsuit, the choreo and the hair are obviously iconic, the "Womanizer" video is arguably more interesting so I went with that one.. 

song wise though.. I mean c'mon.. it's obviously "Oops".. 

[colormefresh]

19 minutes ago, ILikeChillinWithYou said:

Yes, as you all say, Oops is iconic. The red catsuit is instantly recognisable, the titular phrase is still used to this day. It's a classic.

But youtube views determine how remembered the song is now by the GP dont they? Why is Womanizer leading by a small margin in that area if Womanizer came nowhere near the icon status as Oops? 

Plus, music wise, Oops sounds dated while Womanizer could still pass off as electro-pop right? 

Oops came out before YouTube existed.

If you added all the TRL views and people sitting next to their radio to hear the song, Oops would break anyone’s record. Fact.

[Peter Pan]

I love both but Oops takes the crown for both questions! 

[Lorenzo]

40 minutes ago, ILikeChillinWithYou said:

Yes, as you all say, Oops is iconic. The red catsuit is instantly recognisable, the titular phrase is still used to this day. It's a classic.

But youtube views determine how remembered the song is now by the GP dont they? Why is Womanizer leading by a small margin in that area if Womanizer came nowhere near the icon status as Oops? 

Plus, music wise, Oops sounds dated while Womanizer could still pass off as electro-pop right? 

Well Oops is more streamed on Spotify and by a large margin. Maybe Womanizer has more YouTube views because it came out just a couple years before VEVO

[falka]

9 minutes ago, Lorenzo said:

Well Oops is more streamed on Spotify and by a large margin. Maybe Womanizer has more YouTube views because it came out just a couple years before VEVO

Didn't Womanizer lost some views, I remember weird shifts in numbers

 

[BritneyBliss]

I prefer listening to Womanizer

However the Oops video is iconic and im a sucker for that late 90's, early 2000's pop nostalgia 

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

1 hour ago, colormefresh said:

Womanizer was a cute moment but Oops is pop history. 

Yes.  

[falka]

Ops is the one iconic  but I rather watch Womanizer, despite Britney not being first lady I saw naked  Europeans are more filthy from early ages I guess, Brit had no chance.

[RealLarryRudolph]

Chillin with chu outsold both 

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

1 hour ago, RealLarryRudolph said:

Chillin with chu outsold both 

Combined. Verified.