music I wonder how Milkshake, Umbrella and Whiplash would have sounded

[Cedric]

if Britney included them on Britney Blackout and Circus respectively, I can totally see Britney sing Milkshake with her I'm a slave 4 u's voice, Whiplash with her Lace and Leather/Liar's voice and Umbrella with her Body Ache  unleaked songs' voice, especially Rebellion or 911, we could only wish but were we worthy of such gems in Britney's discography considering it's already an A+++ 

[falka]

I'm all for it, with an exception of Umbrella, who needs that crap anyway  

[LiamM]

Honestly they’re probably completely different especially umbrella, whiplash it probably very similar to Salami’s because it’s similar style to Britney’s hopefully they leak eventually IF they exist. 

[Avatar]

I can't hear her singing Umbrella.

[IoI]

.

[DollyParton]

27 minutes ago, Avatar said:

I can't hear her singing Umbrella.

Thats probably exactly why she skipped that song. Sorry, but i really don't think this song would've worked for Britney. 

[breathe_on_me_toxic]

It worked with telephone so it would work with umbrella. but i am not sure about milkshake

[studlygeorge]

4 hours ago, JKW said:

Thats probably exactly why she skipped that song. Sorry, but i really don't think this song would've worked for Britney. 

The only reason it was skipped was because the Umbrella incident was so soon, but I really can’t hear her singing it either. Same with milkshake

[Britneylandia]

The answer is better, they would sound better.

[Brat]

I don’t even like Rihanna’s version of Umbrella,  but I would love to hear a Britney version of Milkshake 

[Good4Ya]

Milkshake is such an iconic bop 

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

8 minutes ago, Good4Ya said:

Milkshake is such an iconic bop 

Yes Ma’am it is iconic!  

 

And it slays, it still slays.  

[Cedric]

Umbrella shade? not on this thread henny 

[Spearsfan]

I wish we would have got umbrella tbh

Milkshake is a bop but it’s hard for me to imagine Britney singing it tbh 

[sibode]

Milkshake has an iconic line, but the song turns out freaking boring after 2 choruses tbh

[IamMax]

Whiplash is the song I need in my life. It's SO Britney. 

[DollyParton]

14 hours ago, Breathe on me u toxicbitch said:

It worked with telephone so it would work with umbrella. but i am not sure about milkshake

Britney’s version of telephone was horroble tho 

[breathe_on_me_toxic]

11 minutes ago, JKW said:

Britney’s version of telephone was horroble tho 

i really liked it . obvl the quality of the demo was low as it was sneaked out of the studio

[Isla]

Britney did record Whiplash, I always thought she could have pulled off the pre-chorus which is sung in a British accent. I hope her version leaks one day.

As for Milkshake and Umbrella, I honestly can’t see Britney singing either of those songs so I’m glad she didn’t record them in the end.

[really really cool guy]

I can only imagine her singing Milkshake and I think it would have been great. Umbrella doesn't fit her voice and Whiplash is trash