exhale A full Chaotic or My Prerogative Album? (POLL)

[MmmDani]

Which EP would you rather have had expanded into an album? Chaotic or My Prerogative (treating the three tracks as a stand-alone EP)

I personally prefer My Prerogative, but I think Chaotic would’ve been more interesting. She was in a really strange place, but with My Prerogative she hadn’t progressed much further than ITZ. My Prerogative would be ITZ 2.0 and Chaotic would be something quite different. But I think I’d have liked MP more

[stateofgracebritney]

MP would end up morphing into OD so... that’s what I choose

[femmefataledoll]

100% MP, I've never been that interested in Chaotic  Although, wasn't MP recorded for ITZ? Or did I make that up?

[LeglessJamie]

Do Somethin' is my jam out of all these songs that were released on those 2 albums

[Avatar]

Wasn’t the MP just the reject ITZ songs? 

[CristMont]

Chaotic is trash 

[UcanLookButDontTouch]

If with Chaotic we get songs like Mona Lisa (Rebellion, Baby boy, State of Grace) then I vote for Chaotic  !

[0973BH]

My prerogative I loved the visuals the song had and would've loved an album with such visuals aswell. 

[bigreputxtion]

MP would make an way better album

but chaotic would be more interesting 

[breathe_on_me_toxic]

Guilty was meant to be seconds single after mp and it had the same tone - i love it so much. more tragic than the not happening of outrageous. and it even had the oriental touch of pcds buttons 2 years earlier!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmsX6SwWxjI

 

 

[I Can Bang]

48 minutes ago, UcanLookButDontTouch said:

If with Chaotic we get songs like Mona Lisa (Rebellion, Baby boy, State of Grace) then I vote for Chaotic  !

This 

[samwoods321]

That whole time for me personally bleeds together so i kinda think of ITZ, MP & CHAOTIC as an album itself, an era if you like. i always forget about the hidden jems of that era like over 2 u, and then we kiss & someday

[PokemonSpears]

For me both feel more like ITZ extensions, but I guess I'd pick MP.

Chaotic, I like that Britney albums have variety (instead of the overrated cohesiveness Exhale loves) but it's too all over the place. 

[MmmDani]

11 hours ago, PokemonSpears said:

For me both feel more like ITZ extensions, but I guess I'd pick MP.

Chaotic, I like that Britney albums have variety (instead of the overrated cohesiveness Exhale loves) but it's too all over the place. 

 

12 hours ago, samwoods321 said:

That whole time for me personally bleeds together so i kinda think of ITZ, MP & CHAOTIC as an album itself, an era if you like. i always forget about the hidden jems of that era like over 2 u, and then we kiss & someday

I totally agree, I never really separate them in my mind. But, they both go in different directions, and I’d be interested in seeing where either path (sonically) lead her. 

I dont think that Chaotic is all over the place, (apart from OTYN, that’s definitely from ITZ) the production is similar enough on all of the tracks that they feel cohesive. If it was expanded into an album I think it would feel less messy, it’s just a compilation of different album tracks really

[PokemonSpears]

1 hour ago, MmmDani said:

 

I totally agree, I never really separate them in my mind. But, they both go in different directions, and I’d be interested in seeing where either path (sonically) lead her. 

I dont think that Chaotic is all over the place, (apart from OTYN, that’s definitely from ITZ) the production is similar enough on all of the tracks that they feel cohesive. If it was expanded into an album I think it would feel less messy, it’s just a compilation of different album tracks really

Chaotic, Mona Lisa, Someday, Over to You Now  I think that would be like making an EP of 3, Scream & Shout, Ooh La La and Pretty Girls and I think even that would have more sense. I don't know, it seems just like random songs placed together.

MP, DS, I've Just begun are more, sonically, like a darker, funkier, stronger version of ITZ. There's also ATWK which I don't know where would it fall, but that's also better than Chaotic

[MmmDani]

1 hour ago, PokemonSpears said:

MP, DS, I've Just begun are more, sonically, like a darker, funkier, stronger version of ITZ. There's also ATWK which I don't know where would it fall, but that's also better than Chaotic

I love the My Prerogative tracks, they’re probably better than the Chaotic ones. But I think Chaotic would’ve made for a far more different project, it would’ve been more interesting imo. MP would’ve been a bit too similar to ITZ. (A MP album would’ve sold better, but it’d be too much of a repeat of ITZ)