Phonography or Telephone?

[MrLovett]

I'm listening to Phonography right now (such a great bop btw ) and since both "Phonography" and "Telephone" are about calling/being called by someone (even tho Phonography's about phone *** and Telephone about dancing in a club but that doesn't matter) and Britney recorded them both for Circus I'd like to know which song do you guys think is better considering Britney's Telephone would have been full produced and stuff.

I personally like the dark vibes of Phonography but the final version of Telephone would've been such an awesome Britney bop. Still mad about Gaga stealing her own song from the queen 

 

How do you guys think? Discuss.

[PieceofBritney]

Definitely Phonography

[celebration2009]

I prefer Phonography because of it's dark sound (very Blackout-ish). The only good thing about Telephone was Bey's part  (which Britney wouldn't have).

[none]

i'd have to listen to a final version of Telephone to decide. The one we have sounds more like a demo

[overprotected_leo]

I like both, but Telephone will have been such a huge hit for Britney, it is so her style 

[ohoney]

Telephone full and polished ver. is not even out, so is not a fair comparison, i'll pick 'Phonography'. 

[naturalplayboy]

did Gaga try to give britney the finger by putting bey on the track because she didnt use it

[neel21]

Phonography.

[sue the expectional earner]

let's talk about biology, phonography phonography talk th...  

[BoyToySoldier]

They made the right choice, Phonography is the superior track. It's Bloodshy & Avant after all.

Telephone is pretty **** now when you listen to it. Gaga can keep it. 

[Guest $elfish]

I love phonography but I have more memories with telephone 

the demo track for telephone by Britney is nice but it's too auto tuned 

I wish britney took the telephone offer and featured it as a bonus track or something would have slayed 

i cant choose ...

[redacted statement]

For Circus Telephone would make more sense. If Phonography and Telephone were from the Blackout era then I'd say Phonography. 

[TheLightningThief]

Phonography is obviously superior.

Telephone is boring. Can't believe Gaga chose this for a single rather than Monster or Dance in the Dark.

[MissSpearsSaysSo]

Phoneography. It was my JAM back in college. 

[One Of a Kind]

Telephone is basic, Phonography is not. Deserved to be a single and not just a bonus track. 

[WilderWein]

Phonography. Its more mature and dark. Cant compare really, only thing they have alike is the fact that it has to do with phones and britney

[Lou M. Taylor]

I prefer Phonography but Britney shouldn't have refused to collab with Gaga on Telephone 

[3isacharm]

Phonography

3 minutes ago, button said:

I prefer Phonography but Britney shouldn't have refused to collab with Gaga on Telephone 

It was never to be a collab. It was supposed to be Britney's song. Rejected it for Circus but wanted it for TSC however Gaga released it w/ Beyonce

[Lou M. Taylor]

1 minute ago, 3isacharm said:

It was never to be a collab. It was supposed to be Britney's song. Rejected it for Circus but wanted it for TSC however Gaga released it w/ Beyonce

No I'm pretty sure Gaga wanted Britney on it before asking Beyoncé

[BRING THE NOISE]

phonography