Slave VS Dirrty

[radar89]

49 minutes ago, david lachapelle said:

I'm in no way a Christana stan... Slave is one of Britney's least remembered classics. 

This is the truth and i'm not gonna bother getting into an arument with biased britney fans on a britney website. 

I am REALLY starting to believe that you are really a Britney's hater in disguise 

1. You are one of the few users who ALWAYS upvote people who talk trash about Britney 

2. From your recent post, you consider Glory to be as bad as Pretty Gorilla and Brenda Joan 

3. You defended Gaga and talked trash about Britney's sales in your last week post  

I am too lazy to dig up the previous Exhale posts but you guys are definitely going to find this turd did the three points that I mentioned above

4. And you said another outlandish thing again in this thread saying that Dirrty is more remembered than Slave. Hunty, Slave, the performance, the costu., the song, the dance, the fckn snake is more remembered than any Xtuna's videos 

Can we ban this poor excuse of human please 

[Artsy Fartsy]

on the US - Dirrty

on the rest of the world - Slave

[nonoiseplz]

Just now, Artsy Fartsy said:

on the US - Dirrty

on the rest of the world - Slave

The US don't know it either. 

[Artsy Fartsy]

2 minutes ago, nonoiseplz said:

The US don't know it either. 

poor Xtine 

[justkeepdoingit]

some of you need to get out more. "dirrty" more well-known... lmfao stahp 

[Lou M. Taylor]

Dirrty's video and hook is pretty iconic, especially in the UK. It carried Stripped's success over there.

Slave wins because of the VMA performance. It has the better visuals anyways.

But we're not discussing quality are we?

 

[nonoiseplz]

Just now, button said:

Dirrty's video and hook is pretty iconic, especially in the UK. It carried Stripped's success over there.

Slave wins because of the VMA performance.

 

Oh Ok. Then it must be a UK thing because it didn't do **** here. 

[Lou M. Taylor]

4 minutes ago, nonoiseplz said:

Oh Ok. Then it must be a UK thing because it didn't do **** here. 

I don't live in the UK but it was pretty successful in Europe overall. It caused controversy in Asia too because of "Underage Thai prostitutes" writing in the video. It kinda caused a shitstorm.

Slave didn't do **** in the US either because of the radio ban, it was lucky to have THE VMA performance and Britney performed it everywhere.

I think Xtina's era didn't take off until Beautiful, she abandoned Dirrty pretty early.

 

[austsilva]

57 minutes ago, david lachapelle said:

I'm in no way a Christana stan... Slave is one of Britney's least remembered classics. 

This is the truth and i'm not gonna bother getting into an arument with biased britney fans on a britney website. 

Where are you getting this into your head tho? Slave is one her MOST iconic hits, the snake, the sweating bodies, and the undies over pants in the mv. The choreo EVERYTHING about slave is iconic even the lyrics. "Getitgetit/kittykitty

[The_Original_Toy]

I'm sorry, when people carry snakes on their backs who do they think of? Britney 

When people enter the boxing ring with a bikini and dreadlocks who do they think of? No one 

[Lou M. Taylor]

Slave definitely wins in the iconic department

But I like both songs equally. It's Xtina's best imo

[On the Scene]

Who the hell voted for Dirrty? Have some class.

 

 

(Jk..not really)

[RafaelSpears]

Just because that ho Kylie wearing a Dirtyyy custome for Halloween doesnt mean that Dirrtyyyy mv is iconic or nor the outfit.  This is like the most stupid statement to make. There's nothing iconic about the Dirtyyy mv. No one outside this or Floptina's fanbase remember that video. 

[david lachapelle]

2 hours ago, radar89 said:

I am REALLY starting to believe that you are really a Britney's hater in disguise 

1. You are one of the few users who ALWAYS upvote people who talk trash about Britney 

2. From your recent post, you consider Glory to be as bad as Pretty Gorilla and Brenda Joan 

3. You defended Gaga and talked trash about Britney's sales in your last week post  

I am too lazy to dig up the previous Exhale posts but you guys are definitely going to find this turd did the three points that I mentioned above

4. And you said another outlandish thing again in this thread saying that Dirrty is more remembered than Slave. Hunty, Slave, the performance, the costu., the song, the dance, the fckn snake is more remembered than any Xtuna's videos 

Can we ban this poor excuse of human please 

 

first of all, i am NOT a hater. britney is my favorite pop girl and that's fact, don't think otherwise just because i don't agree with your extremely biased opinions... let me respond to your four points.

1. this is usually because i agree with them, they're just normal thoughts from other users here. what i upvote/downvote shouldn't matter to you.

2. okay, and? so because i don't like Glory i'm a hater? i just don't like Glory, it's as simple as that. i LOVE all of her other albums, but Glory really disappointed me... there's a lot of things i don't like about the album. that's a normal opinion, i don't even know why that's a problem to you when, again, i love ALL of her other albums. 

3. i defended Gaga because it's irritating how all of you people bash Gaga for no reason... i don't even like her that much (i just like her songs), but there were more than three Gaga hate threads in the britney section within that SAME week. excuse me for sticking up for an artists against you crazy users that act like the beehive.

4. okay... it IS more remembered? whatever, even if it isn't, at least she didn't have to use a gimmick (banana). this may sound rude, but just like with Gaga, i'm saying this because of the RIDICULOUS christina hate...  like, jeez, and you people call ME negative...? 

 

[ManOnTheM00n]

3 hours ago, naturalplayboy said:

Did this question come from Kylie jennahs halloween costume?

SAME THOUGHT

[me.against.the.b00ty]

the only promo xtinct can get nowadays is kylie jenner dressing as her when will ur fave?

[David.]

just because kylie is a big **** and decided to dress as dirrty doesnt mean it is the more iconic one

slave is 

[poriyos]

They both can't be compared.

Slave is iconic music-wise for its choreography, sound, and performance, and more remembered and known by the GP

while Dirrty is iconic for Christina's look at that time (Stripped era) which is shown most in Dirrty music video.

bottom line. Slave stands out as a song and performance, while dirrty for its look

[David.]

3 hours ago, GetBack98 said:

Slave by far although I feel neither music videos are iconic, I mean Slave is mostly referenced because of the iconic VMAs performance not the video.

Why are some of y'all saying Xtina's video is trashy? Acting like our fave isn't performing in a thong everynight at Vegas  not to mention many OHT performances that are way more ******. 

its not about outfits or concept its the overall thing 

she is dancing in a see trough shirt on some dirrty *** showers, also the rap scene where you can see a bunch of different settings of shirtless or naked people all sweaty and stained of god knows what

also the choreography was trashy

its just a try hard trashy mess even tho that xtina>>>>>>> any other of her eras

[Mantequilla]

I mean, the MTV performance made it a very memorable song. I really don't get why some people say Dirrty is more remembered by people. I love both songs, but I've never seen/read people referencing Dirrty as much as Slave.