Slave VS Dirrty

[TheVirtuoso]

I'm A Slave 4 U is obivously more iconic but I like them both equally, maybe Dirrty a little more because of the adlibs and vocal runs she does but Brit just sounds so **** idk.

[Sliver]

1 hour ago, Camilo said:

Are you serious with this? Slave: music video, performance everything 

 

[Britney M. Carey]

Music-wise: Slave

MV-wise: Dirrty (more shocking)

MV outfit-wise: Dirrty (more iconic)

Live performance-wise: Slave (obviously)

[Anti-Hero]

I just looked it up and Dirrty only reached #48 on the Billboard 100. I'm surprised tbh.

[Zinaida Zazekina]

I hope this thread wasn't made just cuz one on the Jenner's dressep up as Xtina 's dirrrrty costume. 

 

Slave is a better song, the beat, the flows, the delivery and ofc the iconic music video, the outfit and performance. It's timeless. 

[nonoiseplz]

1 hour ago, david lachapelle said:

Dirrty is more remembered while Slave is better.

Now thats damn lie.

Just because some reality TV show flop decided to dress up like Floptina in the "Dirrty" music video this year for Halloween, you floptina stans wanna act like that song didn't flop and that music video is iconic.
"Dirtty" flopped and that video is not iconic. You've had 14 years to accept this truth.

[nonoiseplz]

7 minutes ago, danny1994 said:

I just looked it up and Dirrty only reached #48 on the Billboard 100. I'm surprised tbh.

Dirtty flopped hardcore and radio was not blacklisting her like they did Britney from 2001 to 2004.

 

4 minutes ago, Zinaida Zazekina said:

I hope this thread wasn't made just cuz one on the Jenner's dressep up as Xtina 's dirrrrty costume.

you KNOW that is the ONLY reason.

[david lachapelle]

2 minutes ago, nonoiseplz said:

Now thats damn lie.

Just because some reality TV show flop decided to dress up like Floptina in the "Dirrty" music video this year, you floptina stans wanna act like that song didn't flop and that music video is iconic.
"Dirtty" flopped and that video is not iconic. You've had 14 years to accept this truth.

I'm in no way a Christana stan... Slave is one of Britney's least remembered classics. 

This is the truth and i'm not gonna bother getting into an arument with biased britney fans on a britney website. 

[ChrisTheLoner]

Is this a trick question sis?

It's pretty obvious that Slave is miles better than that cheap mess. Slave is classy **** while Dirrty is just trashy

[nonoiseplz]

5 hours ago, david lachapelle said:

I'm in no way a Christana stan... Slave is one of Britney's least remembered classics. 

This is the truth and i'm not gonna bother getting into an arument with biased britney fans on a britney website. 

Even if Slave is one of Britneys least remembered classics ( which its not), Dirttty still isn't close to being as remembered.

just the thought me singing the line "Wanna get dirty! " around a group of people makes me Ohhhhhhhhhhh . Nobody would have a ******  clue what I'm talking about.

[GetBack98]

Slave by far although I feel neither music videos are iconic, I mean Slave is mostly referenced because of the iconic VMAs performance not the video.

Why are some of y'all saying Xtina's video is trashy? Acting like our fave isn't performing in a thong everynight at Vegas  not to mention many OHT performances that are way more ******. 

[softskeleton]

Slave is obviously better than Dirty, musically and also the video... It is **** and kinda raunchy but not vulgar like Dirrty. But you guys shouldn't pretend Dirrty isn't remember by people. Everyone who was old enough at the time to remember and liked pop music remembers that song and video.

[shadowaddict]

Both are iconic. But Slave >>>>>>>> Dirrty 

[BOBIBCFBG]

Slave is the better song, the better video, the better choreography, the better live performances, the better outfits, it did better on the charts, ect ect ect 

[Guest StrawberryKisses]

Slave is REALLY iconic. Like REALLY.  Sorry Xtina.

[nonoiseplz]

9 minutes ago, softskeleton said:

Slave is obviously better than Dirty, musically and also the video... It is **** and kinda raunchy but not vulgar like Dirrty. But you guys shouldn't pretend Dirrty isn't remember by people. Everyone who was old enough at the time to remember and liked pop music remembers that song and video.

Yea,  only those kids who were watching during the months it played on MTV. 

Like "Slave" , Dirrty didn't get much radio airplay but Britneys VMA 2001 performance of "I'm a Slave 4 U" became iconic and has made/ continues to make people check out the song and music video. That is why "Slave 4 U" is the more well known song and video.

"Dirty" is as memorable as any other flop single she has released after "Beautiful".

[lirebelde]

4 hours ago, david lachapelle said:

I'm in no way a Christana stan... Slave is one of Britney's least remembered classics. 

This is the truth and i'm not gonna bother getting into an arument with biased britney fans on a britney website. 

Girl put the pieces together, slave has one of the most iconic performances on pop scene in the last 20 years which is remembered by the media year after year, dirty haven't that and if you search on internet you gonna find that slave still has more audience than dirty , nobody talks about dirty but i guess jenner dressed witth the ouffit have christina fans on the moon.

[troubleguy]

is that even a question? 

i like dirty, but screams ruins the song 

[tsss]

Dirty mv is too vulgar for me, the only look I love from Stripped era is The Voice Within 

of course I will prefer Britney's song 

[nonoiseplz]

8 minutes ago, lirebelde said:

Girl put the pieces together, slave has one of the most iconic performances on pop scene in the 20 last years which is remembered by the media year after year, dirty  haven't  that and if you search on internet you gonna find that slave still has more audience than dirty , nobody talks about dirty but i guess jenner dressed witth the ouffit have christina fans on the moon.

Flotpinas refugee fans are on Pluto!

6 minutes ago, Erreur 2 La Nature said:

No shade even if I don't like Xtina, but I've never ever heard "Dirrty" in real life

Imagine yourself walking into  a room of strangers and saying the line "Wanna get Dirty!",   Even though the song itself is embarrassing to sing,  they will have no idea what you're talking about!

Floptina's music is something that only pop STANS who were listening to teen pop in the early 2000's know.